PDA

View Full Version : Need Serious Advice on this trade



Amars
09-28-2005, 05:04 PM
I have Palmer and this guy who winning in my league wants him. He offered Big Ben for him. Of couse I said no. I told him it would have to be a package deal that included Brian Westbrook. What package of player should I offer and what should I recieve from him. Or should I offer him at all.We can start QB, RB,WR,TE, 2Flex,K,Def.


Here is my Roster
Starters
Palmer, Carson QB CIN
Johnson, Rudi RB CIN
McAllister, Deuce RB NO
Portis, Clinton RB WAS
Jackson, Darrell WR SEA
Miller, Heath TE PIT
Nugent, Mike K NYJ
Panthers, DST DST CAR

Reserves
Warner, Kurt QB ARI
Arrington, J.J. RB ARI
Bennett, Drew WR TEN
Boldin, Anquan WR ARI
Calico, Tyrone WR TEN
Curtis, Kevin WR STL
Williams, Mike WR DET
Heiden, Steve TE CLE
Stover, Matt K BAL
Cowboys, DST DAL

Here is his Roster

Starters
Collins, Kerry QB OAK
Jordan, LaMont RB OAK
Westbrook, Brian RB PHI
Williams, Carnell RB TB
Galloway, Joey WR TB
Gates, Antonio TE SD
Peterson, Todd K ATL
Eagles, DST DST PHI

Reserve
Losman, J.P. QB BUF
Orton, Kyle QB
Roethlisberger, Ben QB PIT
Bettis, Jerome RB PIT
Gore, Frank RB SF
Booker, Marty WR MIA
McDonald, Shaun WR STL
Stokley, Brandon WR IND
Baker, Chris TE NYJ
Chiefs, DST KC


I dont belive the hype with Carnell Williams and I beleive will break down when I need him the most. Kerry Collins is ok fantasy wise. Brian Westbrook is good but MCNABB is Really hurt. Antonio Gates is a upgrade but brees is not having that stellar of year like last year. My team is healthy and no weakness only in TE. So what do you guys think. Thanks for your input.

Amars
09-28-2005, 05:11 PM
I believe he's one starter hurt from ruining his fantasy season

RAS25
09-28-2005, 05:18 PM
i wouldnt trade palmer hes a stud your rbs are good..id stay put

Kucha
09-28-2005, 05:23 PM
You will have no viable starting QB if you trade Carson Palmer away...and you seem to have decent RB's as they are. You'd be adding depth at RB while taking away your only start level QB. Am I reading this wrong? Seems like a bad deal to me.

I wouldn't even think of doing this if he didn't offer you Westbrook and Kerry Collins as a package for Palmer. I know it sounds one sided but you gotta protect your interests. If he wants him that bad, let him pay for it. If not, he can go away.

Amars
09-28-2005, 05:29 PM
Well I was think Westbrook, Collins, and Gates for Palmer, Duece, and Boldin.

Mile High Fin
09-28-2005, 06:55 PM
Well I was think Westbrook, Collins, and Gates for Palmer, Duece, and Boldin.


Yeah, that sounds fair...

You upgrade RB and REALLY upgrade TE

Doesn't hurt you for WR.

You take a downgrade (somewhat) at QB.

Advantage: You.

hunter5nc1
09-28-2005, 09:15 PM
I would offer him

Palmer, Heiden, Arrington
4
Westbrook, Gates, Ben

Kucha
09-29-2005, 03:09 PM
Well I was think Westbrook, Collins, and Gates for Palmer, Duece, and Boldin.

Ok, that sounds better. I think I'd go for ths trade then.

Dolfan81
09-29-2005, 11:11 PM
i wouldnt give up palmer at all
rite now he is the best fantasy QB out there especially with mcnabb hurt, id keep him
i have him as a starter for a number one team

hunter5nc1
09-29-2005, 11:58 PM
i wouldnt give up palmer at all
rite now he is the best fantasy QB out there especially with mcnabb hurt, id keep him
i have him as a starter for a number one team


Thats exactly why you should trade him. Don't forget he has 4 games against the Steelers and the Ravens

Slappy8800
09-30-2005, 12:01 AM
i wouldnt trade him either