PDA

View Full Version : For whoever doubted kastofsna120:



Flying Pencil
01-10-2006, 05:23 AM
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/5233672

Larry Fitzgerald finished 5th in All-Pro voting for wide receiver. :evil:

Motion
01-10-2006, 06:56 AM
So did he get banned? Haven't seen him in awhile and I saw some comments from people that would suggest he has been.

King Felix
01-10-2006, 01:05 PM
that doesnt mean he is top 5 wr

King Felix
01-10-2006, 01:06 PM
cuz if it did michael vick is top 5 qb 2

unifiedtheory
01-10-2006, 01:54 PM
Larry Fitzgerald in 2005

Receptions: 103
NFL ranking: 1st

Recieving yards: 1,409
NFL ranking: 4th

T.D. receptions: 10
NFL ranking: 7th

Seems to me that his numbers put him in the top 5....I certainly think he is. I think it is a good idea to remind everyone he's only in his second season. His AVERAGE over those 2 seasons is:

80 catches, 1090 yards and 9 T.D.'s

His AVERAGE over two seasons (his only 2 seasons) are the same as Chris Chambers' career season. People around here are putting Chris in the Hall Of Fame after having the year he did this year yet, Fitzgerald gets comments like "he's a top 5 reciever?". Make up your mind.

FrankP
01-10-2006, 02:22 PM
If he is not the in the top-5, who is?

I think he is up there... considering he did this with no run game support and Warner and McCown throwing to him and Boldin...

backpacker
01-10-2006, 03:15 PM
^ Yeah Boldin and Fitzgerald ruled the NFL this year, both being in the top 5 for receiving yards. It's hard to believe a team is losing like that with their starting 2 receivers being 4th and 5th.

dominizzo
01-10-2006, 03:47 PM
truueee where is KAastofsna

Alex44
01-10-2006, 03:49 PM
Sorry he plays on a pass happy team and hasnt proven consistancy yet over a few seasons

He will be a top 5 guy in the future but as of now i dont think he is

unifiedtheory
01-10-2006, 07:23 PM
Sorry he plays on a pass happy team and hasnt proven consistancy yet over a few seasons

He will be a top 5 guy in the future but as of now i dont think he is

Has'nt been consistent? I would argue he was the most consistent reciever in the NFL this year.

He only had less then 4 receptions in a game one time this year, had 7 games of over 100 yards, had 70+ receiving yards 12 times and scored a TD in 10 different games.

Those numbers tell me that the guy does what he does all the time. He had rediculous numbers this year but it is not like he had 4 crazy games and was pretty average for the other 12 (cough....Chris Chambers....cough).

And before someone says "well, he was never dominant like Chambers was sometimes this year" he had 7 games of at least 7 receptions and 100 yards.

FinaciousOne
01-10-2006, 07:32 PM
Sorry he plays on a pass happy team and hasnt proven consistancy yet over a few seasons



Then a rookie could never be a top 5 reciever?

King Felix
01-10-2006, 10:23 PM
1.marvin harrison
2.to
3.randy moss
4.torry holt
5.chad johson

now take out attitudes and go purely skill whod u rather have??

unifiedtheory
01-10-2006, 10:33 PM
1.marvin harrison
2.to
3.randy moss
4.torry holt
5.chad johson

now take out attitudes and go purely skill whod u rather have??

You put T.O. and Randy Moss in a sentence and said NOT to discuss attitude?:sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol:

I'll take Torry Holt over Moss, Owens and Harrison anyway.

Alex44
01-10-2006, 10:34 PM
Then a rookie could never be a top 5 reciever?


No they cant be

Stat wise they can be, but overall no

Alex44
01-10-2006, 10:36 PM
Has'nt been consistent? I would argue he was the most consistent reciever in the NFL this year.

He only had less then 4 receptions in a game one time this year, had 7 games of over 100 yards, had 70+ receiving yards 12 times and scored a TD in 10 different games.

Those numbers tell me that the guy does what he does all the time. He had rediculous numbers this year but it is not like he had 4 crazy games and was pretty average for the other 12 (cough....Chris Chambers....cough).

And before someone says "well, he was never dominant like Chambers was sometimes this year" he had 7 games of at least 7 receptions and 100 yards.

I said consistant over a long period of time not just this year

And I never said chambers was better or even suggested that

1- Torry Holt
2- Randy Moss *when healthy*
3-Chad Johnson
4- Marvin Harrison
5- Steve Smith
6- TO
7- Fitzgerald here maybe

King Felix
01-10-2006, 10:52 PM
You put T.O. and Randy Moss in a sentence and said NOT to discuss attitude?:sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol:

I'll take Torry Holt over Moss, Owens and Harrison anyway.


atitude doesnt make u top 5 skill does so purely skill wise those r the top 5 in no particular order

K-train
01-10-2006, 11:06 PM
I said consistant over a long period of time not just this year

And I never said chambers was better or even suggested that

1- Torry Holt
2- Randy Moss *when healthy*
3-Chad Johnson
4- Marvin Harrison
5- Steve Smith
6- TO
7- Fitzgerald here maybe

Randy Moss going and bombing people on pass routes is what he is 1# in.

But do you ever see Moss go towards the middle?

Fitzgerald is Top 6.

Prime
01-10-2006, 11:06 PM
truueee where is KAastofsna


He got banned for making ignorant comments all the time.

dominizzo
01-10-2006, 11:31 PM
He got banned for making ignorant comments all the time.

wooow iguess he got banned for life:sidelol:

King Felix
01-11-2006, 12:05 AM
lol

unifiedtheory
01-11-2006, 12:09 AM
I said consistant over a long period of time not just this year

And I never said chambers was better or even suggested that

1- Torry Holt
2- Randy Moss *when healthy*
3-Chad Johnson
4- Marvin Harrison
5- Steve Smith
6- TO
7- Fitzgerald here maybe

I was just using Chambers as an example...it was not directed at you.

Randy Moss has'nt been healthy for 2 years...a trend.

T.O. is'nt even in my top 100...I don't care if he catches 150 passes for 2000 yards and 20 T.D.'s...the guy is a cancer and will throw his coach/Q.B./team under the bus when ever he is not getting attention. The guy is a whiny 10 year old girl in a 31 year old reciever's body.

I'll take Fitz over every reciever you listed accept Steve Smith and Torry Holt.

unifiedtheory
01-11-2006, 12:11 AM
atitude doesnt make u top 5 skill does so purely skill wise those r the top 5 in no particular order

I'll take the high skilled TEAM player before I take an immature moron who cares about nothing but himself and his payday.

unifiedtheory
01-11-2006, 12:12 AM
He got banned for making ignorant comments all the time.

You don't get banned for making ignorant comments.

If that was the case their would be about 100 people banned a day.

dominizzo
01-11-2006, 12:49 AM
You don't get banned for making ignorant comments.

If that was the case their would be about 100 people banned a day.


Right On Unified

WharfRat
01-11-2006, 02:51 PM
I'll take the high skilled TEAM player before I take an immature moron who cares about nothing but himself and his payday.

:yeahthat: :clap:

WharfRat
01-11-2006, 02:55 PM
He got banned for making ignorant comments all the time.

Actually, he was banned for repeatedly resorting to personal insults, even after several warnings and a handfull of "timeouts".
We gave him numerous chances, yet he refused to be civil.

PassRush
01-11-2006, 03:14 PM
Chad Johnson
TO
Marvin Harrison
Randy Moss
Torry Holt

Alex44
01-11-2006, 03:22 PM
I was just using Chambers as an example...it was not directed at you.

Randy Moss has'nt been healthy for 2 years...a trend.

T.O. is'nt even in my top 100...I don't care if he catches 150 passes for 2000 yards and 20 T.D.'s...the guy is a cancer and will throw his coach/Q.B./team under the bus when ever he is not getting attention. The guy is a whiny 10 year old girl in a 31 year old reciever's body.

I'll take Fitz over every reciever you listed accept Steve Smith and Torry Holt.


I hate TO but skill wise he is top 5 or 6, although i wouldnt want him anywhere near my team

Fitzgerald plays on a pass happy team so his numbers are a little inflated IMO

If you want to see the best WR since Jerry Rice watch Torry Holt because he is the best route runner and sure handed WR in the league since Jerry

Fitz is a top 10 WR but other guys have proved it for longer and deserve the 5 spots more i think

The Confessor
01-11-2006, 03:24 PM
Actually, he was banned for repeatedly resorting to personal insults, even after several warnings and a handfull of "timeouts".
We gave him numerous chances, yet he refused to be civil.

Question to MODS: In all due respect, is he banned indefinately? If so, bummer cuase I sure liked getting him stirred up..... :D

Sorry, I promise to play nice again... No more shock treatment guys.... PLEASE:goof:

OH yeah, and about the subject, I would LOVE to have L. Fitz on any team I was routing for.. Guy has got it all, and appears to be a very good person, both locker room and community....

dolphinfan2k5
01-11-2006, 05:55 PM
Hmm, that's too bad, I think he was pretty knowledgable he was just mean too people. But if you don't take it personal cause you know he does it it isn't bad. Oh well.

bg34
01-11-2006, 08:41 PM
1. Holt
2. Harrison
3. Boldin
4. Fitzgerald
5. S.Smith
6. C.Johnson

Boldin> Fitzgerald...IMO

The Confessor
01-11-2006, 08:43 PM
1. Holt
2. Harrison
3. Fitzgerald
4. S. Smith
5. Boldin
6. C.Johnson

Hmmmm. Two Cardinals on one list. Dont drop a gernade, you will blow up their entire offense on one post:bombyou: :tank:

bg34
01-11-2006, 08:45 PM
I changed it after thinking more, jmo.