PDA

View Full Version : This draft would thrill me



South Florida
03-03-2006, 01:31 AM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer

Skeet84
03-03-2006, 01:39 AM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle
3 - Marcus Maxey
4 - Marcus Vick
7 - Devin Hester
7 - Jeremy Bloom
7 -

Wow your reaching on Maxey and Marcus Vick Big time!! Hester in the 7th I doubt it same for Jeremy Bloom!
Try this!

1st. WInston Justice
2nd. Jonathan Joseph
3rd. Omar Jacobs
4th. Best LB available
7th. Gerald Riggs Jr ( This is a reach, But I have seen him here )
7th. Best DT available
7th. Best Saftey available

South Florida
03-03-2006, 02:02 AM
I like your style and would be fine with that draft, but to explain on Maxey, Vick and Hester:

Maxey could beef up and be a fast free safety.

Vick ran a 4.4 at the combine. We know he also has an arm.

Hester couldn't start in college and only ran a 4.5 at the combine, so I envision him slipping far down the line.

Bloom only because I just don't see a man at 170 being drafted.

Skeet84
03-03-2006, 02:05 AM
I like your style and would be fine with that draft, but to explain on Maxey, Vick and Hester:

Maxey could beef up and be a fast free safety.

Vick ran a 4.4 at the combine. We know he also has an arm.

Hester couldn't start in college and only ran a 4.5 at the combine, so I envision him slipping far down the line.

Bloom only because I just don't see a man at 170 being drafted.


Maxey could be a good FS however its still a reach.
Vick has way too many issues for anything more than a 7th.
Bloom won't be there in the 7th.
Hester might slip just not that far

Alex44
03-03-2006, 02:05 AM
I like your style and would be fine with that draft, but to explain on Maxey, Vick and Hester:

Maxey could beef up and be a fast free safety.

Vick ran a 4.4 at the combine. We know he also has an arm.

Hester couldn't start in college and only ran a 4.5 at the combine, so I envision him slipping far down the line.

Bloom only because I just don't see a man at 170 being drafted.

Thats his skiing weight, his football weight is 183

He will be a 4th round pick

Pennington's Rocket Arm
03-03-2006, 02:17 AM
i don't like any of the picks.

Danny
03-03-2006, 03:16 AM
i don't like any of the picks.
To be honest, I'm not sure I do either and forget about Vick...we don't need no more head cases.

Ozzy rules!!

Skeet84
03-03-2006, 03:20 AM
To be honest, I'm not sure I do either and forget about Vick...we don't need no more head cases.

Ozzy rules!!

Yeah we don't need him at all!

Canadi-Phin
03-03-2006, 09:21 AM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer

My biggest problem with all these guys is they ahve serious questions about each of them.
MacNeil-back, can he play LT
Croyle-Too small, can he stay healthy
Maxey-Can he get bigger, can he handle big receivers
Vick-What the hell is he thinking?
Hester-Where is he going to play?
Bloom-Can he take the punishment?
Last guys I don't mind both seem like good athletes

I know all players have questions but you want at least one of your picks to be a sure thing, he has the right size, is fast enough, is an athlete, if in the end he doesn't translate then he just could make the trasition. Also Bloom and Hester to go along with Welker. Three return guys, not sure about that. Just feel there is lots of reaching in this mock draft, good thoughts though. IMo

saves
03-03-2006, 12:12 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer


Why do we need to draft so many players at the same positions lol. What are we going to do with 2 more QB's and two more small fast guys to go with the one we already have?

WelcomeBack
03-03-2006, 12:27 PM
Why two QB's? And two rounds apart?

WelcomeBack
03-03-2006, 12:31 PM
I would be happy with this draft:

Rnd 1: Manny Lawson, DE/OLB, N.C. State
Rnd 2: Jason Allen, S, Tennessee
Rnd 3: Omar Jacobs, QB, Bowling Green
Rnd 4: Darrell Hunter, CB, Miami (Oh.)
Rnd 7: Jovon Bouknight, WR, Wyoming
Rnd 7: Domata Peko, DT, Michigan St.
Rnd 7: Albert Toeaina, OT, Tennessee

Philter25
03-03-2006, 12:37 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer

If we took 2 QBs, one being Vick in the FOURTH, I think I would cry. :boohoo:

CD13
03-03-2006, 12:39 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer


You like Marcus don't you. Vick won't get drafted that high, nor would I want that guy on the team. I like Brodie, although I worry that he might not fall to our second round pick. McNeill could be had in a tradedown.

primetime23
03-03-2006, 01:01 PM
why do we need bloom, hes 170 what good can he do to us except return kicks? might as well keep welker

weisdolphins
03-03-2006, 01:14 PM
This would thrill me for the first three rounds.

1.Manny Lawson
2.Darnell Bing
3.Brodie Croyle

but check this one out
http://www.draftdaddy.com/MD/GJH_Mock.cfm

Motion
03-03-2006, 01:17 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer

Horrible draft. Why both Croyle and Vick? Why both Hester and Bloom?

Pointless.

Motion
03-03-2006, 01:18 PM
This would thrill me for the first three rounds.

1.Manny Lawson
2.Darnell Bing
3.Brodie Croyle

but check this one out
http://www.draftdaddy.com/MD/GJH_Mock.cfm

Not very realistic. Croyle will never drop that far.

weisdolphins
03-03-2006, 01:23 PM
Not very realistic. Croyle will never drop that far.

Ok well take out Croyle and put in Cedric Griffin

Motion
03-03-2006, 01:25 PM
Ok well take out Croyle and put in Cedric Griffin

Then we'd be taking 2 DBs in a row.

Rather move Croyle up to the 2nd rounder and sub in Jason Allen as the 3rd rounder.

Boone
03-03-2006, 01:27 PM
Why draft two quarterbacks?

SF Dolphin Fan
03-03-2006, 01:33 PM
I like most of it, but Miami really needs secondary help and this draft doesn't address that.

SF Dolphin Fan
03-03-2006, 01:36 PM
I would be happy with this draft:

Rnd 1: Manny Lawson, DE/OLB, N.C. State
Rnd 2: Jason Allen, S, Tennessee
Rnd 3: Omar Jacobs, QB, Bowling Green
Rnd 4: Darrell Hunter, CB, Miami (Oh.)
Rnd 7: Jovon Bouknight, WR, Wyoming
Rnd 7: Domata Peko, DT, Michigan St.
Rnd 7: Albert Toeaina, OT, Tennessee

I like that draft better, except for no real offensive line help. I really would love to see Miami get both Lawson and Jacobs, though.

FinaticalOne
03-03-2006, 01:39 PM
This would thrill me for the first three rounds.

1.Manny Lawson
2.Darnell Bing
3.Brodie Croyle

but check this one out
http://www.draftdaddy.com/MD/GJH_Mock.cfm

I just check out that site. Not bad. According to your link; I might go this way:

1. Jimmy Williams - Secondary was our achilles heel last year. Even though we have Will Poole and Shirdonya Mitchell coming back from injury to join Travis Daniels in the secondary; it would be hard to pass up on en elite cover corner; especially after the departure of Sam Madison.

2. Darnell Bing/Daniel Bullocks/Andrew Whitworth - Adding Darnell Bing/Daniel Bullocks back there with Yeremiah Bell will be a good tandem. I'm starting to lean towards Bullocks, becasue of his 4.4 speed. If we sign Lance Shulters back; then this position will not need to be addressed this high, therefore; I would draft Whitworth.

3. Omar Jacobs/Brodie Croyle - whichever one falls to us here. Both have questions, so I'll leave the decision up to the braintrust.

canesandphins1
03-03-2006, 01:58 PM
1. Antonio Cromartie CB/S As of today we need DB's and you will not find one as big fast and fluid as this guy

2. Jonathon Scott OT We still need OL

3. Omar Jacobs QB This is just a gut feeling of who we end up with big arm good accuracy strange release the good thing about the release is it is a high release instead of side arm like Vince young
4. Devin Hester WR/KR SPEED

7 Most 7th rounders are fillers and usually don't make the team maybe 1 of 3 will this year but if the cap isn't fixed maybe 2 of 3

7

7

Motion
03-03-2006, 02:24 PM
I don't see Jacobs lasting to the 3rd. He really helped himself at the combine. He's definitely above Whitehurst now. Mid -late 2nd rounder IMO.

Skeet84
03-03-2006, 03:30 PM
I don't see Jacobs lasting to the 3rd. He really helped himself at the combine. He's definitely above Whitehurst now. Mid -late 2nd rounder IMO.


I can't believe how much talent is in the second round of this draft.

musphinzfan
03-03-2006, 03:43 PM
I can't believe how much talent is in the second round of this draft.

Alot of past injury talent...Alot of the guys in the 2nd have some old injuries to have concerns about....I am not saying we dont take a guy like Johnathin Joeseph or some 1 but alot have been injuried...Also a select few.

Joseph SC
Allen TN
Cromartie(probably 1st but very risky there)FSU
Hill CL

thats a few off the top.

I do agree there is talent but alot with a variety of issues INJ,EXP and off field problems.

Motion
03-03-2006, 04:08 PM
Alot of past injury talent...Alot of the guys in the 2nd have some old injuries to have concerns about....I am not saying we dont take a guy like Johnathin Joeseph or some 1 but alot have been injuried...Also a select few.

Joseph SC
Allen TN
Cromartie(probably 1st but very risky there)FSU
Hill CL

thats a few off the top.

I do agree there is talent but alot with a variety of issues INJ,EXP and off field problems.

Joseph and Hill have past injuries?

BTW, very likely that Hill goes in the 1st.

Skeet84
03-03-2006, 04:20 PM
Joseph and Hill have past injuries?

BTW, very likely that Hill goes in the 1st.


Yeah I also did not know that they had past injuries either.

marino1348
03-03-2006, 06:52 PM
wow, I remember when gerarld riggs jr. was talked about as top 3 RB.

weisdolphins
03-04-2006, 12:31 PM
What about this?

1. Manny Lawson DE/OLB
2. Omar Jacobs QB
3. Will Blackmon DB
4. Daniel Bullocks DB
7. Clinton Solomon WR
7. Domata Peko DT
7. Jason Spitz OL

ChambersMIA84
03-04-2006, 12:47 PM
I prefer a Hawkeye

Preferrably Hodge in the 2nd or Hinkel in the 7th

pigskinguy
03-04-2006, 01:03 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer


That punk Vick in the 3rd is laughable and quite silly.

weisdolphins
03-04-2006, 01:16 PM
I prefer a Hawkeye

Preferrably Hodge in the 2nd or Hinkel in the 7th

I have Clinton Solomon in the seventh thats a hawkeye

Dolfan11
03-04-2006, 04:35 PM
1 - Marcus McNeill - Ronnie is used to him, he's 6'7 330, didn't allow a sack in college
2 - Brodie Croyle - cannon
3 - Marcus Maxey - Tall, fast and showed a lot of talent in his only year as a starter
4 - Marcus Vick - I think its worth it.
7 - Devin Hester - Worth it as well
7 - Jeremy Bloom - Could look up to wes welker
7 - Rashaad Butler or Leon Williams - I'm a homer

This is what I would do:

1 - Ernie Sims OLB FSU
2 - Andrew Whitworth OT LSU; if Jonathon Scott OT isn't there
3 - Omar Jacobs QB Bowling Green; he will be there, it's his destiny!
4 - Atwan Allen CB Iowa or Marcus Maxey CB UM

We could package all three 7th round picks (maximum value is 45.6 pts) and possibly get a late 5th and a late 6th or get two mid to late 6th round picks. Assuming we get a late 5th and a late 6th these are my picks:

5 - Justin Wyatt CB USC
6 - Clinton Solomon WR Iowa

I don't have us taking any safeties because I feel Schulters will stay, and Tillman or Bell along with another FA like Will Demps or Marlon Mccree or Tank Williams (I prefer the Tank!)

WelcomeBack
03-04-2006, 04:52 PM
What about this?

1. Manny Lawson DE/OLB
2. Omar Jacobs QB
3. Will Blackmon DB
4. Daniel Bullocks DB
7. Clinton Solomon WR
7. Domata Peko DT
7. Jason Spitz OL


I would be happy with that, but I don't think Bullocks would be there in the 4th. So maybe substitute Pat Watkins, S, Florida St. in that spot. I'd be extremely happy.

jlfin
03-04-2006, 06:07 PM
I like your style and would be fine with that draft, but to explain on Maxey, Vick and Hester:

Maxey could beef up and be a fast free safety.

Vick ran a 4.4 at the combine. We know he also has an arm.

Hester couldn't start in college and only ran a 4.5 at the combine, so I envision him slipping far down the line.

Bloom only because I just don't see a man at 170 being drafted.

Vick will not be drafted. The NFL now realizes that his brother is nothing special and never will be. Neither one of the Vicks will ever be elite QB's. I think it's a joke that Mike Vick ever got anywhere near Hawaii.
Atlanta is slowly realizing that they will never get to the next level with Vick leading their team.
I'd rather see the Dolphins draft Croyle, Jacobs, Whitehurst, Ingle Martin, before throwing away a pick on Vick

Skeet84
03-04-2006, 07:00 PM
Vick will not be drafted. The NFL now realizes that his brother is nothing special and never will be. Neither one of the Vicks will ever be elite QB's. I think it's a joke that Mike Vick ever got anywhere near Hawaii.
Atlanta is slowly realizing that they will never get to the next level with Vick leading their team.
I'd rather see the Dolphins draft Croyle, Jacobs, Whitehurst, Ingle Martin, before throwing away a pick on Vick


I agree. Micheal Vick in the Pro Bowl??? :shakeno: