PDA

View Full Version : American idol fans:Mandisa is gone



Dors156
04-05-2006, 09:31 PM
wow this is strange.simon said she was the best singer on idol and america votes her off.im just glad hicks is still in it but still mandisa got ripped off.bucky is terrible.

bullseyeguy
04-05-2006, 09:54 PM
Hey, thanks for ruining it for me.

DELETE THIS THREAD BEFORE SOMEONE ELSE GETS ****ED OVER!!!!!!!!!!!1

tucker
04-05-2006, 10:18 PM
good..its about time they got rid of her

GRAPEAPE
04-05-2006, 10:40 PM
Elliot survived again! I hate that Jay Fiedler impersonator

Majpain
04-06-2006, 12:08 AM
You could have made the title better.Instead you give a huge spoiler.Btw anyone else like Kat or Kellie I only watch the show because of them.

IronChef
04-06-2006, 12:15 AM
paris is going to take it... now that mandisa is gone paris is goin to pick up all of the votes mandisa would have gotten going further...paris has the best voice IMO.. Kelly is a fake just like underwood..

Majpain
04-06-2006, 12:45 AM
paris is going to take it... now that mandisa is gone paris is goin to pick up all of the votes mandisa would have gotten going further...paris has the best voice IMO.. Kelly is a fake just like underwood..

EWW I cant stand PAris.I hope she gets eliminated.She really doesnt need Idol since here Mom and grandmother are both Musicians.

IronChef
04-06-2006, 01:03 AM
EWW I cant stand PAris.I hope she gets eliminated.She really doesnt need Idol since here Mom and grandmother are both Musicians.


just because her mom and grandmother are singers does not mean that paris doesnt need this.. and its not about NEED, its about talent.. and she has the most of it in comparison to the remaining finalist.. JMO

d-day
04-06-2006, 01:07 AM
bucky needs to go - after him it's a head scratcher - all the rest are really good in their own way especially, katherine mcphee :drool:

Majpain
04-06-2006, 01:53 AM
just because her mom and grandmother are singers does not mean that paris doesnt need this.. and its not about NEED, its about talent.. and she has the most of it in comparison to the remaining finalist.. JMO

:shakeno:

HysterikiLL
04-06-2006, 06:03 AM
I thought that 16 year old black chick was the best.

Motion
04-06-2006, 06:09 AM
paris is going to take it... now that mandisa is gone paris is goin to pick up all of the votes mandisa would have gotten going further...paris has the best voice IMO.. Kelly is a fake just like underwood..

:shakeno: She is one of the most annoying people I've ever seen on TV. Her 6 year old talking voice is like nails on a chalkboard.

njfinfan
04-06-2006, 06:10 AM
Elliot survived again! I hate that Jay Fiedler impersonator


:sidelol: I agree.

Pagan
04-06-2006, 07:03 AM
~ Taylor Hicks is the only one on that show with any soul. He should win but he needs to step it up.
~ Chris is the kind of singer you can find in any club on a Friday or Saturday night. He's pretty much every voice you've heard since '92.
~ Ace is a pretty boy whose falsetto makes me want to strangle him.
~ Elliot looks like a Keebler Elf, but has a good voice.
~ If they do one more "camera on Paris as she cries" shot, my TV's going out the window.
~ Bucky needs to go back to his trailer.
~ Kelly is trying to make everyone thnk she's really that stupid, and it's wearing thin.
~ Katherine's hot but her voice isn't amazing.

In short, probably the worst cast yet on this show. I'm only watching to see how stoned Paula is every week. :wink:

LtDan
04-06-2006, 07:12 AM
I have liked Chris since day one and he is still my choice. I loved his version of "Walk The Line"

Motion
04-06-2006, 07:37 AM
I have liked Chris since day one and he is still my choice. I loved his version of "Walk The Line"


:yes: I agree

bullseyeguy
04-06-2006, 12:34 PM
That was not his version, that was Live's version....

Pagan
04-06-2006, 12:52 PM
That was not his version, that was Live's version....
None of his versions were HIS versions. When he did the Stevie Wonder song Paula was praising him for doing it "his" way, when in fact he did the Chili Pepper's version practically note for note.

The guy has a decent voice, don't get me wrong, but he's every rock club singer you've ever seen over the last 14 years.

And Ace is just this year's Constantine. All flash, no talent.

jmm13-54
04-06-2006, 01:20 PM
When I saw they were going to sing queen songs the next week...I was disappointed that I wouldn't get to hear Mandisa sing fat bottom girls...I'm sure that would have been her pick.

GRAPEAPE
04-06-2006, 01:26 PM
When I saw they were going to sing queen songs the next week...I was disappointed that I wouldn't get to hear Mandisa sing fat bottom girls...I'm sure that would have been her pick.I am really interested to see what songs they do pick. should be a good show.
heres my guess on a few.
EDIT, I found a list of Queen Singles, So here's my pix
Ace - Somebody to Love
Katharine - Who Wants to Live Forever
Bucky - Crazy Little Thing Called Love
Kellie - Killer Queen
Chris - Hammer to Fall (might be too obscure...in that case, We Will Rock You)
Mandisa - We Are the Champions
Elliott - Save Me
Paris - Love of My Life
Taylor - Don't Stop Me Now

dreday
04-06-2006, 01:44 PM
Mandisa and Paris probably have the best voices...But unfortunately for Mandisa I dont think she has the "Look" to be American Idol.Paris better sing the right songs.If Mandisa would lose 80 pounds she would have won.The bald dude is good,I think its gonna come down to Paris and him.

Perfect23
04-06-2006, 01:46 PM
I think that bald dude is gonna win.

ponchovilla
04-06-2006, 01:53 PM
Mandisa peed off allot of ppl with last weeks comments about hoping her music helps some get over their lifestyles. My wife reads Idol message boards like its crack, and the gay community seemed to be mad. When you bring religion into something like idol, you run the risk of turning some ppl off.

Majpain
04-06-2006, 02:17 PM
:shakeno: She is one of the most annoying people I've ever seen on TV. Her 6 year old talking voice is like nails on a chalkboard.

100% agreed.

NaboCane
04-06-2006, 03:12 PM
I don't watch it, but who's the really cute chick that I've seen pictures of? Brunette, very pretty?

dQbell
04-06-2006, 03:15 PM
When I saw they were going to sing queen songs the next week...I was disappointed that I wouldn't get to hear Mandisa sing fat bottom girls...I'm sure that would have been her pick.

"Flying blind on a rocket-cycle?"

d-day
04-06-2006, 04:37 PM
~Taylor Hicks is the only one on that show with any soul. He should win but he needs to step it up.

taylor appears he is the only one with soul but there are others


~ Chris is the kind of singer you can find in any club on a Friday or Saturday night. He's pretty much every voice you've heard since '92.
you're giving club singers too much credit, most club singers suck - chris has a legitimate rock -n- roll voice - the guy's already a star whether he wins or not

~
Ace is a pretty boy whose falsetto makes me want to strangle him.

ace, has unbelievable falsetto - pretty boy or not, ace has talent


~ Elliot looks like a Keebler Elf, but has a good voice.

dio looks like an elf, elliot has an amazing voice

~
If they do one more "camera on Paris as she cries" shot, my TV's going out the window.

paris is probably the most gifted singer on the show - the girls 16 singing in front of millions - she is a sweetheart


~ Bucky needs to go back to his trailer.

AGREE


~ Kelly is trying to make everyone thnk she's really that stupid, and it's wearing thin.

kelly will be making pornos in 2 months


~ Katherine's hot but her voice isn't amazing.

katherine is not only hot but she parlays her looks with an amazing voice - the girl is a star in the making



In short, probably the worst cast yet on this show. I'm only watching to see how stoned Paula is every week.:wink:


definitely the best collection of individual talent yet at american idol...

luv ya pagan... :tongue:

In_Flames
04-06-2006, 04:47 PM
first off let me state that I am not a fan of this show, however, my wife is, therefore I am forced to watch it :wink: ...with that being said...Im rooting for Chris D. & and my wife is rooting for Katherine M. to make it to the final two and win...

Pagan
04-06-2006, 04:51 PM
taylor appears he is the only one with soul but there are others
When he walked into the judging room with the harmonica, he showed he was the coolest person on the show.


you're giving club singers too much credit, most club singers suck - chris has a legitimate rock -n- roll voice - the guy's already a star whether he wins or not
Of course he is, the music industry signs EVERY cookie-cutter singer and band that comes along. :lol:


ace, has unbelievable falsetto - pretty boy or not, ace has talent
Falsetto isn't a talent. If it was King Diamond would be the greatest singer on earth. It's called falsetto for a reason.


dio looks like an elf, elliot has an amazing voice
Elliot couldn't lick the bottom of Dio's shoes talentwise. BAD analogy! :lol:


paris is probably the most gifted singer on the show - the girls 16 singing in front of millions - she is a sweetheart
Agreed. Her crying just annoys me! :lol:


kelly will be making pornos in 2 months
We can only hope! :lol:


katherine is not only hot but she parlays her looks with an amazing voice - the girl is a star in the making
Agreed...if she starts choosing better songs.


definitely the best collection of individual talent yet at american idol...
But again....you like HAIR bands! :tongue:


luv ya pagan... :tongue:
Love ya too bro...we need our own thread for debates. :lol:

d-day
04-06-2006, 05:11 PM
When he walked into the judging room with the harmonica, he showed he was the coolest person on the show.

agreed coolest but not the only one with soul

Originally Posted by Pagan
~Taylor Hicks is the only one on that show with any soul. He should win but he needs to step it up.





Of course he is, the music industry signs EVERY cookie-cutter singer and band that comes along.

so your saying that you can go in any club on any given night and find a singer just as good or better than chris...?! :eek: :chuckle: - if that was the case, every club band would have a record deal - chris could sing for any "todays" rock band any day




Falsetto isn't a talent. If it was King Diamond would be the greatest singer on earth. It's called falsetto for a reason.

it's not huh? tell that to the remaining members of queen




Elliot couldn't lick the bottom of Dio's shoes talentwise. BAD analogy!

i love dio - bad comparison indeed but elliot technically is the best singer on the show - did you hear him sing the james moody song? dio couldn't do that - (please lets not start a elliot vs dio debate :lol: )




Agreed. Her crying just annoys me!

looks like we got a draw here :wink:




We can only hope! :lol:

:yes: and another draw




Agreed...if she starts choosing better songs.

:yes:



But again....you like HAIR bands! :tongue:


i love hair bands especially the guitar players: vito bratta, nuno, warren d, jake e lee etc. (let's see you argue that one... :tongue: )




Love ya too bro...we need our own thread for debates. :lol:

you bet...

NaboCane
04-06-2006, 05:12 PM
Oh for godsake, you guys are discussing this like it matters! What matters is who is the cute brunette! :tongue:

In_Flames
04-06-2006, 05:14 PM
Oh for godsake, you guys are discussing this like it matters! What matters is who is the cute brunette! :tongue:

http://www.finheaven.com/clear.gifmmmmmm...:wink:

Pagan
04-06-2006, 05:17 PM
agreed coolest but not the only one with soul
Okay, the one with the MOST soul. Better? :tongue:


so your saying that you can go in any club on any given night and find a singer just as good or better than chris...?! :eek: :chuckle: - if that was the case, every club band would have a record deal - chris could sing for any "todays" rock band any day
And that's a good thing? You of all people should know that talent doesn't get you a record deal. The Knack, anyone?

And I don't know how it is in Florida, but in NY there are a bunch of guys who sing just like him. That drab, boring monotone.


]it's not huh? tell that to the remaining members of queen
Ah but you forget something, brother D-Day...when Queen didn't falsetto, they could actually SING. Ace cannot.


i love dio - bad comparison indeed but elliot technically is the best singer on the show - did you hear him sing the james moody song? dio couldn't do that - (please lets not start a elliot vs dio debate :lol: )
Disagree. I think Paris is technically the best singer.


i love hair bands especially the guitar players: vito bratta, nuno, warren d, jake e lee etc. (let's see you argue that one... :tongue: )
I would never argue with you on that. Now on hair band singers we have another discussion completely...and this competition is about SINGERS. So when I said that you liking hair bands renders your judgement of the "talent" on this year's show a little less valid, that's what I was basing it on. :lol:


you bet...
Let the games begin! :lol:

Pagan
04-06-2006, 05:22 PM
Oh for godsake, you guys are discussing this like it matters! What matters is who is the cute brunette! :tongue:
Shhhhhh....me and D-Day just love messing with each other. :wink: :lol:

In_Flames
04-06-2006, 05:26 PM
Shhhhhh....me and D-Day just love messing with each other. :wink: :lol:

:peck:





:lol:

Pagan
04-06-2006, 05:29 PM
:peck:





:lol:
HEY NOW!!!! Listen here "Death Metal Boy"!!!!!

:lol:

d-day
04-06-2006, 05:32 PM
And I don't know how it is in Florida, but in NY there are a bunch of guys who sing just like him. That drab, boring monotone.

i know you hate that type of singing, but even you have to admit, the guy has great tone - and he had very good phrasing - he is very good at what he does, not o.k. or mediocre but very good - just giving credit where it's due




Ah but you forget something, brother D-Day...when Queen didn't falsetto, they could actually SING. Ace cannot.

agreed - just debating your notion that there is no talent in falsetto - ace can't sing a lick but his falsetto is really quite good






I would never argue with you on that. Now on hair band singers we have another discussion completely...and this competition is about SINGERS. So when I said that you liking hair bands renders your judgement of the "talent" on this year's show a little less valid, that's what I was basing it on. :lol:

lets talk hair band singers - now were they technically the best singers of any genre? - no way - i'll give you that but a singer isn't always defined by his vocal ability - david lee for example - not technically the best singer but the guy had personality and that what makes him one of the greats - stephen pearcy, taime downe, steve whitman, all qualify in that department - but lets also not forget some real talented singers to come from that era - how about paul shortino, david king, and tony harnell, all money on the pipes... :dday:




Let the games begin! :lol:

whatcha got...?!

In_Flames
04-06-2006, 05:33 PM
HEY NOW!!!! Listen here "Death Metal Boy"!!!!!

:lol:


hey now..don't pigeonhole me...I like to stay diverse in my Metaldom...I also like melodic death metal, black metal, and hell throw alil doom metal in as well..:D

NaboCane
04-06-2006, 06:55 PM
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/katharine.jpgmmmmmm...:wink:

Yes! I have to have her.

NaboCane
04-06-2006, 07:01 PM
Shhhhhh....me and D-Day just love messing with each other. :wink: :lol:

:lol: nah, really?

Dors156
04-06-2006, 07:15 PM
I have liked Chris since day one and he is still my choice. I loved his version of "Walk The Line"


i liked that to.i think he will win it.him and hicks are my favorites but hicks wont win it

Dors156
04-06-2006, 07:16 PM
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/katharine.jpgmmmmmm...:wink:


shes pretty hot

23_Phins_84
04-06-2006, 08:27 PM
ok Ill break it down for you.
Males:
Chris
Elliot
Taylor
Ace
Bucky

Females:
..........hmmm cant really decide
ok. Theyre all on the bottom

23_Phins_84
04-06-2006, 08:28 PM
:barf:
shes pretty hot

In_Flames
04-06-2006, 08:53 PM
:barf:

you'll feel differently once you hit puberty...:wink: jk

dQbell
04-06-2006, 09:23 PM
Shhhhhh....me and D-Day just love messing with each other. :wink: :lol:

You and D-Day remind me of those two old Muppits on the Muppit Show that would heckle from the top balcony.:cooldude:

Motion
04-07-2006, 07:55 AM
:barf:
:shakeno:


you'll feel differently once you hit puberty...:wink: jk

:yes: :clap: