PDA

View Full Version : Rate these Dolphin players on the Speilstadt scale



Anthony D.
05-27-2006, 02:47 AM
A.J. Feeley:
Jay Fiedler:
Eddie Moore:
Derrius Thompson:
David Boston:
Sage Rosenfells:
Lamar Gordon:
James McNight:
Taylor Whitley:
Greg German:
Jamar Fletcher:
Todd Wade:
Ben Kelley:


Use the following scale:

10 = destined to NFL hall of fame
9 = an elite NFL talent at his position for years
8 = a very good NFL talent at his position for years
7 = a solid NFL talent at his position for years (5-7)
6 = a solid NFL talent for a few seasons (2-3)
5 = a solid role player, but never a solid starter
4 = a career backup for 3-5 years
3 = after 3 years of not producing, out of the league
2 = after 2 years of not producing, out of the league
1 = destined to NFL hall of shame (out of league in 1 year)

And remember, this is according to Spielman and Wandstadt's views.

Anthony D.
05-27-2006, 02:50 AM
A.J. Feeley:10
Jay Fiedler:9
Eddie Moore:11
Derrius Thompson:8
David Boston:9
Sage Rosenfells:3
Lamar Gordon:7
James McNight:7
Taylor Whitley:7
Greg German:7
Jamar Fletcher:8
Todd Wade:8
Ben Kelley:7

ShuggieOtis
05-27-2006, 02:55 AM
you forgot everyone's fav....Reggie Howard! Hes definitely a 16

Anthony D.
05-27-2006, 02:58 AM
In reality:In my opinion:


A.J. Feeley:4
Jay Fiedler:5
Eddie Moore:3
Derrius Thompson:4
David Boston:5
Sage Rosenfells:6
Lamar Gordon:5
James McNight:5
Taylor Whitley:4
Greg German:4
Jamar Fletcher:5
Todd Wade:4
Ben Kelley:5

painnotpleasure
05-27-2006, 04:46 AM
In my opinion:

A.J. Feeley: 4
Jay Fiedler: 5
Eddie Moore: 3
Derrius Thompson: 4
David Boston: 6
Sage Rosenfels: 5
Lamar Gordon: 5
James McKnight: 5
Taylor Whitley: 4
Greg Jerman: 4
Jamar Fletcher: 5
Todd Wade: 6
Ben Kelley: 3

Spielman/Wanny

A.J. Feeley: 10
Jay Fiedler: 10
Eddie Moore: 9
Derrius Thompson: 7
David Boston: 7
Sage Rosenfels: 5
Lamar Gordon: 9
James McKnight: 6
Taylor Whitley: 9
Greg Jerman: 4
Jamar Fletcher: 9
Todd Wade: 6
Ben Kelley: 3

LarryFinFan
05-27-2006, 07:25 AM
A.J. Feeley: 2 (just brought him in here for laughs and to get Spielman fired too)
Jay Fiedler: 101 (or as I refer to him...Brett Favre)
Eddie Moore: 31 (my finest hour as a GM, well when he gets off IR besides, we didn't need a WR opposite CC, we had McKnight)
Derrius Thompson: 12 (best WR avialable considering the QBs I'll have throwing to him.)
David Boston: 28 (Just wait, he'll produce...sometime, somewhere)
Sage Rosenfells: 14 (Only as a backup, no one challenges Ears)
Lamar Gordon: 22 (Ricky ?? We don't need no stinking Ricky)
James McNight: 12 (See Derrius Thompson remarks)
Taylor Whitley: 16 (This kid can develop...we don't need OL anyways)
Greg German: 43 (You can get by with PS scrubs on your team in the OL, don't worry)
Jamar Fletcher: 57 (Just because he didn't fit my D scheme, who cares...we didn't have any other needs)
Todd Wade: 0 (he left me, so I hate him now)
Ben Kelley: (Uh...did I draft him ??)

Signed...Dave Wannstache...

BlueFin
05-27-2006, 08:05 AM
Whats incredible is how many Dolphin fans defended this bumbling pair so ardently for years.

Geforce
05-27-2006, 08:19 AM
I thought James McNight-mare was a JJ signee?

FinsFan71
05-27-2006, 08:20 AM
A.J. Feeley:
Jay Fiedler:
Eddie Moore:
Derrius Thompson:
David Boston:
Sage Rosenfells:
Lamar Gordon:
James McNight:
Taylor Whitley:
Greg German:
Jamar Fletcher:
Todd Wade:
Ben Kelley:


Use the following scale:

10 = destined to NFL hall of fame
9 = an elite NFL talent at his position for years
8 = a very good NFL talent at his position for years
7 = a solid NFL talent at his position for years (5-7)
6 = a solid NFL talent for a few seasons (2-3)
5 = a solid role player, but never a solid starter
4 = a career backup for 3-5 years
3 = after 3 years of not producing, out of the league
2 = after 2 years of not producing, out of the league
1 = destined to NFL hall of shame (out of league in 1 year)

And remember, this is according to Spielman and Wandstadt's views.

Fiedler: 8
Moore: 6
Thompson: 6 or 7
Boston: 10
Rosenfels: 5 or 6
Gordon: 8 or 9
McKnight: 6
Whitley: 5 or 6
German: 5 or 6
Fletcher: 9 or 9 1/2
Wade: 9
Kelley: solid 7

FinsFan71
05-27-2006, 08:25 AM
Feeley: 9 or 9 1/2
Gardner: 9
Howard: 10
And of course Ricky Williams: 50 plus on both their scales> Wanny even said one time, "Ricky can "Smoke" anyone and anything!!!" :sidelol:

"RICKY WILL SMOKE YA!!!" :sidelol: :sidelol: :sidelol: :sidelol: :sidelol:

FinsFan71
05-27-2006, 08:27 AM
If the truth be told

Only Boston and Ricky are above average players.

everyone else is a 5 or below by the scale.