PDA

View Full Version : the first 3 rounds



Phinsfan-Jay
02-18-2007, 10:38 PM
Trade Chambers for a 2nd rounder possibly to Minnesota. I love him but im sick of using numbers to justify his value to this team positive or negative, its getting old. We still have booker welker and hagan. Then with our hypothetical draft here.

1st round - Dwayne Jarrett
2nd round - Ryan Kalil
2nd rounder (minnesota) - either brandon siler. buster davis. lamar woodley.
3rd round- Drew Stanton

Aqua4Ever04
02-18-2007, 10:52 PM
Trade Chambers for a second round pick, what a waste that would be.

CitizenSnips
02-18-2007, 10:56 PM
Dont EVER predict trades when suggesting an offseason draft. I hate it. What int he world makes you think miami wants to trade chambers, what in the world makes you think Minny wants to trade for Chambers, A 2nd rounder no less?

How can you suggest something so strong with no real evidence to even suggest that Minny or Miami would even be slightly interested?

Put madden away.

finfan75
02-18-2007, 11:01 PM
We don't need high paid WR to win a super bowl. We need consistent receivers that catch the ball. Maybe he would shape up if he knew he was going to be traded.

MIAdolphin89
02-18-2007, 11:12 PM
We don't need high paid WR to win a super bowl. We need consistent receivers that catch the ball. Maybe he would shape up if he knew he was going to be traded.

shape up? you think the fear of being traded will make him catch balls better? because i guess he's just dropping balls out there on purpose.

Phinsfan-Jay
02-18-2007, 11:16 PM
first off dude i can post whatever i want. thats the way i think we should go about doing it i just threw minny in there because they are in the market for a WR. chambers isnt worth any more than a mid 2nd rounder im sorry. if you think otherwise your kidding yourself. not to mention hes never one to be counted on ever. its always the 5 catch game for 28 yrds and the occasional 3 for 112 like once a season. but other than his 2005 campaign and 2003 ive been hoping for so much more out of him idk i know this year was just crazy with welker really emerging along side booker and chambers and mc michael but dont ever tell someone on this site that they cant post something football not to mention dolphin related you got it.

Roman529
02-18-2007, 11:23 PM
Ginn Jr. would solve a lot of problems at WR.....not only does he have unreal speed but he has great hands and knows how to run once he catches it. We need a game breaker and I think Ginn will be it.

CitizenSnips
02-18-2007, 11:27 PM
first off dude i can post whatever i want. thats the way i think we should go about doing it i just threw minny in there because they are in the market for a WR. chambers isnt worth any more than a mid 2nd rounder im sorry. if you think otherwise your kidding yourself. not to mention hes never one to be counted on ever. its always the 5 catch game for 28 yrds and the occasional 3 for 112 like once a season. but other than his 2005 campaign and 2003 ive been hoping for so much more out of him idk i know this year was just crazy with welker really emerging along side booker and chambers and mc michael but dont ever tell someone on this site that they cant post something football not to mention dolphin related you got it.

:lol:Was that a threat?

Actually i believe the reverse, Chambers isn't even worth a 2nd IMO. A 3rd maybe, but not really after last season.

I'm simply pointing out that it's absolutely pointless to include a theoretical trade in any type of situation. Maybe if there was one, just one, article that hinted on miami looking to trade Chambers, then you can start throwing these nonsense trade ideas around. However, i have not read anywhere YET.

Phanatical
02-18-2007, 11:31 PM
:lol:Was that a threat?

Actually i believe the reverse, Chambers isn't even worth a 2nd IMO. A 3rd maybe, but not really after last season.

I'm simply pointing out that it's absolutely pointless to include a theoretical trade in any type of situation. Maybe if there was one, just one, article that hinted on miami looking to trade Chambers, then you can start throwing these nonsense trade ideas around. However, i have not read anywhere YET.

I don't think that trading Chambers for a 2nd round pick is pointless or nonsense. Makes perfect sense and he only said "possibly" to Minnesota.

CitizenSnips
02-18-2007, 11:33 PM
I don't think that trading Chambers for a 2nd round pick is pointless or nonsense. Makes perfect sense and he only said "possibly" to Minnesota.
Have the dolphins shown they're looking to trade chambers? Has Minnesota shown their looking to trade for Chambers? Or a Receiver in General?

Phanatical
02-18-2007, 11:36 PM
Have the dolphins shown they're looking to trade chambers? Has Minnesota shown their looking to trade for Chambers? Or a Receiver in General?

No, but that wasn't his point. His point was just that he felt the Dolphins should try to trade Chambers for a #2 pick. I don't think he said that it's gonna happen.

CitizenSnips
02-18-2007, 11:43 PM
No, but that wasn't his point. His point was just that he felt the Dolphins should try to trade Chambers for a #2 pick. I don't think he said that it's gonna happen.

How did you get that from this?

Trade Chambers for a 2nd rounder possibly to Minnesota.

Now maybe if he writes
"i believe the dolphins should..."
"If i was the Gm i would look to..."
"Hypothetically speaking, if i could runt he dolphins from this point on, i would..."

Phanatical
02-18-2007, 11:46 PM
How did you get that from this?


Now maybe if he writes
"i believe the dolphins should..."
"If i was the Gm i would look to..."
"Hypothetically speaking, if i could runt he dolphins from this point on, i would..."

Yeah, OK, whatever. You're ripping on the poor guy for making a hypothetical when about 99% of the threads and posts on here are just that. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense, nice work. :shakeno:

Minnphin
02-18-2007, 11:51 PM
How did you get that from this?


Now maybe if he writes
"i believe the dolphins should..."
"If i was the Gm i would look to..."
"Hypothetically speaking, if i could runt he dolphins from this point on, i would..."

It was written as a command. Now unless you believe that he believes that anybody in the phins front office reads this board and would listen to him, it's pretty clear he's saying, "They should." It's a draft thread. It's a draft thread trade idea. This post is no different than saying, "Draft Ted Ginn Jr." They've never expressed interest in Ginn, but that doesn't mean somebody can't hope that. In closing, I don't get why you got so pissy about it.

Phanatical
02-18-2007, 11:54 PM
It was written as a command. Now unless you believe that he believes that anybody in the phins front office reads this board and would listen to him, it's pretty clear he's saying, "They should." It's a draft thread. It's a draft thread trade idea. This post is no different than saying, "Draft Ted Ginn Jr." They've never expressed interest in Ginn, but that doesn't mean somebody can't hope that. In closing, I don't get why you got so pissy about it.

:yeahthat:!!!

Geforce
02-19-2007, 12:06 AM
Trade Chambers for a 2nd rounder possibly to Minnesota. I love him but im sick of using numbers to justify his value to this team positive or negative, its getting old. We still have booker welker and hagan. Then with our hypothetical draft here.

1st round - Dwayne Jarrett
2nd round - Ryan Kalil
2nd rounder (minnesota) - either brandon siler. buster davis. lamar woodley.
3rd round- Drew Stanton
Okay you trade Chambers and draft Jarrett? We now have 4 possession receivers (Jarrett, Booker, Welker & Hagan) and no one to stretch the defense to free up the underneath passes. How is that an improvement?

Caldolfan
02-19-2007, 12:06 AM
At least there was no mention of drafting Quinn in this thread.

Tureo
02-19-2007, 12:10 AM
Trade Chambers for a 2nd rounder possibly to Minnesota. I love him but im sick of using numbers to justify his value to this team positive or negative, its getting old. We still have booker welker and hagan. Then with our hypothetical draft here.

1st round - Dwayne Jarrett
2nd round - Ryan Kalil
2nd rounder (minnesota) - either brandon siler. buster davis. lamar woodley.
3rd round- Drew Stanton
We wouldn't get a 2nd rd pick for CC and I am not sure Jarret would be enough to replace him. We would have 0 speed at the WR position and that may have been one the problems with this years team according to our GM.

malzj
02-19-2007, 12:13 AM
Welker emerged? To say any of our receivers had a good season is crazy. He caught more passes then Chambers but it's not like Welker lit up the NFL. To many people have been watching the movie Invincible and so they're rooting for the little guy. Never mind his production returning kickoffs and punt returns suffered... but lets not talk about that. Welker is dependable and that's about it. Chambers is a game breaker and there's a lot of people that want to rip him because he had a down year when the receivers as a whole didn't really do anything.

DownUnderFin13
02-19-2007, 12:31 AM
Okay you trade Chambers and draft Jarrett? We now have 4 possession receivers (Jarrett, Booker, Welker & Hagan) and no one to stretch the defense to free up the underneath passes. How is that an improvement?
I was thinking the same thing. Where is our speed receiver ? :dolphins:

djphinfan
02-19-2007, 02:26 AM
Ginn Jr. would solve a lot of problems at WR.....not only does he have unreal speed but he has great hands and knows how to run once he catches it. We need a game breaker and I think Ginn will be it.YOU my friend are a VERY smart man,,,I too would like a GINN n tonic on draft day

SQuinn17
02-19-2007, 03:22 AM
chambers for a second rounder yah right!!!! they would never go for that.

CANDolphan
02-19-2007, 05:10 AM
Ginn Jr. would solve a lot of problems at WR.....not only does he have unreal speed but he has great hands and knows how to run once he catches it. We need a game breaker and I think Ginn will be it.



but he has great hands




great hands

:sidelol:

miamiron
02-19-2007, 05:24 AM
Trade Chambers for a second round pick, what a waste that would be.

For which team????

miamiron
02-19-2007, 05:26 AM
At least there was no mention of drafting Quinn in this thread.

Or trading up and giving our future away!!

Elliott 1
02-19-2007, 07:53 AM
Trade Chambers for a 2nd rounder possibly to Minnesota. I love him but im sick of using numbers to justify his value to this team positive or negative, its getting old. We still have booker welker and hagan. Then with our hypothetical draft here.

1st round - Dwayne Jarrett
2nd round - Ryan Kalil
2nd rounder (minnesota) - either brandon siler. buster davis. lamar woodley.
3rd round- Drew Stanton

Four 1st day draft picks and the only way even one of them starts is if we trade Rex Hadnot, or trade Booker and Chambers. But Jarrett will have a hard time even beating out Hagan, seeing he's a rookie and Hagan played well at the end of last year.

We can take a receiver in a later round. Trading down and taking Jarvis Moss or Laron Landry is more palatable for my taste.

Minnesota may trade with us but we'd have to sweeten the pot. Chambers isn't worth a 2nd by himself. I wish he was...sigh

I think Samson Satele will be the better C/G in the long run and he might still be there at the #71.

Ginn may even fall to the 2nd round if he has a mediocre pro-day. We could use him if Welker is taken away.

I was a Stanton fan but Zabransky in the later rounds looks more and more like the steal of the 07 draft to me. Not much risk with a 6 or 7th pick. But blowing it on the 1st day could damage us for years. I like sure things like Okoye if we don't keep Holiday, Branch if we cut Wilkinson and/or trade Manny Wright. Or if we trade down there's also Puz and Willis, very close to sure thing 1st year starters.

SAY NO TO DRAFTING GUYS WITH THIS,"Intelligence????????" , IN THEIR SCOUTING REPORTS

zonk4ever
02-19-2007, 10:23 AM
Dont EVER predict trades when suggesting an offseason draft. I hate it. What int he world makes you think miami wants to trade chambers, what in the world makes you think Minny wants to trade for Chambers, A 2nd rounder no less?

How can you suggest something so strong with no real evidence to even suggest that Minny or Miami would even be slightly interested?

Put madden away.
__________________
Everyone is entitled to express their hypothetical trade scenarios. With 2 months to go to the draft, these kinds of posts are "so hypothetical" they are annoying. (IMO) Everyone is entitled to their own / my opinion.