PDA

View Full Version : you be the Gm over the past 10 years



crumpdaddy
04-07-2007, 12:08 AM
okay all ive only posted sporatically here and there. with draft time coming up we all dream of being GM and picking the stars to make our boys a championship team. so heres what we do for the bored ones. over the past 10 years, not your mock draft but who you wouldve legitamately taken with the pick available. see where the team mightve turned out have we been in charge. and if ya need help with who was available at time of our pick go to http://www.nfl.com/draft/history/years/2006
ok for me, let me try not to ruin our beloved franchise
2006
1-manny lawson (played outside moved crowder to other ilb)
2-culp (trade)
3-brodie crole (in case pep didnt pan out..i know doesnt make sense 2 and 3 on qb)
2005
1-aaron rogers (im trying to find qb for decade to come)
2-roscoe parish (quick and agile, mightve never went with welker)
3- ryan moats (ughh but remember we didnt get brown in first round)
2004
1-losman (everyone was kissing his but before draft...poor bills)
2-
3- no 2 or 3 thanks wanny, sheesh i spent first day pick on lossman
2003
1-ricky i thinky
2-eddie more jk..mike doss...wouldve been great with sammy and pat
3-
3-undecided about this draft was sober for it so dont remember well and dont want to be biased
2002
1-ricky i thinky
2-no pick, sheesh our high picks
3-DAVIS GARRARD!!!! i went to ecu i still want this guy as a dolphin before he retires
2001
1-i was pissed when freddie mitchell was drafted ahead of us so would go with reggie wayne (wow he couldve made LUCAS look good)
2-travis henry (we needed rb and he was best rb available..wow this is turning into a good draft)
3-kenyatta jones.back up for dixon i believe at the time
3b- bpa?
2000
1-gone
2-chris redmon (whewwww. but needed marinos replacement)
3-ben kelly (yeah we had him, i was even thinking maybe draft him in 2nd at time...wow)
1999
1-?
2-peerless price (needed some real weapons on outside and he was best weapon avail)
3-cecil the diesel...yes i thought this highly of him!!! i know we draft him in the 5th but oh well
1998
1-randy moss wouldve been OURS!!!!
2-brian kelly, sorry surtain but usc sees a lil better comp
2b- michael ricks (quick tell me who was TE back then)
3a-larry shannon ( i know we got moss in first round but remember ECU! and we drafted him with 3b....this guy shouldve been good)
3b- i dont care im happy i got moss and shannon, give me best kicker available
1997
1- ill admit yatil green <sigh>
2-freddie jones, read above quick who was TE...i screwed up and missed on mad
3-im going out on a limb and saying i KNOW i would draft jason taylor right here, no im not cheating i would legitamately drafted him, i promise

so if youre everyday crump was gm
06-remains ot be seen
05-ughh
04-lossman ya right blaghh
03-too sober to remember
02-ricky and garrard im happy
01-reggie wayne and travis henry YA!
00-sucked
99-okay at best if cecil doesnt get arrested
98-moss yeah good draft, never trade down before your pick comes available!!!
97- i honestly wouldve picked taylor in the third!!! so this is best draft ever for us :-D

i know any reply would take a lot of time, but aye thats whats beer is for. so tell us how good of a gm you would've been.. btw hope yall enjoyed the read, it took 8 beers and an hour to do it :-) lets go phins!!!!!!

*my first memory in life was marino and montana at pepsi machine, marino was supposed to be there for many more

Mari0k
04-07-2007, 12:24 AM
Losman..OEMGEE>>lol..poor bills

djavelin
04-07-2007, 01:23 AM
None of that made any sense.

OneHondo
04-07-2007, 01:29 AM
2006
1 - Nick Mangold
2 - Marcus McNeil ( didn't trade for DC)
3 - Brodie Croyle
4 - Gabe Watson
5 - XXX (used for Manny Wright)
6 - XXX
7 - Marques Colston
7 - Rodrique Wright

2005
1 - Ronnie Brown
2 - Khalif Barnes
3 - Channing Crowder
4 - Kerry Rhodes
5 - Anttaj Hawthorne
6 - XXX
7 - Kevin Vickerson

2004
1 - Vince Wilfork
2 - XXX
3 - XXX
4 - Nat Dorsey
5 - Drew Carter
6 - Rex Hadnot
7 - Carlos Joseph
7 - Derrick Pope

2003
1 - XXX
2 - Anquan Boldin
3 - Derrick Dockery
3 - Angelo Crowell
4 - XXX
5 - Dan Koppen
5 - Langston Moore
6 - Cato June
6 - Siddeeq Shabazz
7 - Scott Shanle

2002
1 - XXX
2 - XXX
3 - Chris Hope
4 - Randy McMichael
5 - Verron Haynes
5 - Josh Shaw
6 - XXX
7 - David Givens

2001
1 - Drew Brees
2 - Chris Chambers
3 - Casey Rabach
4 -

Sorry, can't do it any more! After I saw Jamar Fletchers name I got too depressed to finish. Man, Miami has has some really bad, lousy drafts. Almost makes you want to go get sick or something. Maybe if I went outside and threw something agains't the side of the house I will feel better. Yukkk.....

dolfan2334
04-07-2007, 02:19 AM
None of that made any sense.

agreed.

that was the most sporadic thing ive ever read

djavelin
04-07-2007, 05:22 AM
OK so heres my take.The main rounds are selected,but the later rounds some i really couldnt pick.So heres my go at it.



1997


#15-1st.Tony Gonzalez-TE
#44-2nd.Sam Madison-CB
#73-3rd.Jason Taylor-DE
#92-3rd.Derrick Mason-WR
#93-3rd.Derrick Rodgers-LB
#96-3rd.Brent Smith-G


1998


#29-1st.Flozell Adams-T
#44-2nd.Pat Surtain-CB
#49-2nd.Kenny Mixon-DE
#79-3rd.Hines Ward-WR
#82-3rd.Brian Griese-QB
#102-4th.Lorenzo Bromell-DE...Broke Peytons Jaw.
#143-5th.John Wade-C
#171-6th.Fred Beasly-FB
#172-6th.Matt Birk-C.....Matt Hasselback-QB


1999

#39-2nd.Dre Bly-CB
#43-2nd.Joey Porter-LB
#72-3rd.Marty Booker-WR
#142-4th.David Bowens-DE



2000


#53-3rd.Todd Wde-T
#84-4th.Jeff Ulbrich-LB
#115-4th.Dante Hall-WR/KR
#152-5th.Ernest Grant-DT
#167-6th.Marc Bulger-QB




2001


#26-1st.Reggie Wayne-WR
#52-2nd.Chris Chambers-WR
#85-3rd.Jonas Jennings-T
#88-3rd.Rudi Johnson-RB





2002


#90-3rd.Chris Hope-SS
#114-4th.Randy Mc-TE



2003


#49-2nd.Anquan Boldin-WR
#78-3rd.Derrick Dockery-G
#87-3rd.Chris Brown-RB
#156-5th.Dan Koppen-C
#169-5th.Yeremiah Bell-SS


2004

#19-1st.Vernon Carey-T
#102-4th.Nathan Vasher-CB
#160-5th.Rex Hadnot-G
#174-6th.Derrick Pope-LB






2005


#2-1st.Ronnie Brown-RB
#46-2nd.Matt Roth-DE
#70-3rd.Channing Crowder-LB
#104-4th.Travis Daniels-CB
#162-5th.Anthony Alabi-G
#216-7th.Kevin Vickerson-DT




2006


#16-1st.Manny Lawson-LB

Not trade for Pepp
I dont know what pick we had 48 or 51
So if we had the pick before SD

#48-2nd.Marcus McNeil-G

If not IDK...................

#82-3RD.Derek Hagan-WR

5th rnd supplemental draft-Manny Wright-DT

#212-7th.Fred Evans-DT
#226-7th.Rod Wright-DT


GO DOLPHINS...................#1 :cooldude:

eomdtbtr
04-07-2007, 12:11 PM
I'm not very old, so I'm only going to do more recent drafts.

2001: 1st Chad Johnson ( seriously I remember thinking how good this guy was going to be, don't know why, just did)
2nd: Gary Baxter
3rd: Cory Bird (Yeah I know)

2002: 3rd: trade up, Jeff Hatch

2003: 2nd: I'll admit it, I wanted Eddie Moore
3rd: Chris Simms, but at the time I never thought he would become a starter, just picked him, because we had no good QB, and needed a project.
2004: 1st: Vernon Carey (local boy)

2005: 1st:Trade up, Alex Smith
2nd: Matt Roth
3rd: Verand Morency ( Sry Channing)

2006: 1st: Laurence Maroney
3rd: Brodie Croyle

Pocoloco
04-07-2007, 01:52 PM
I'll admit that I was on the McPherson bandwagon a couple of years ago. I probably would have drafted him in the third instead of Crowder, which would have been a mistake

VT Dolphan
04-07-2007, 01:59 PM
None of that made any sense.

Maybe it had something to do with those 8 beers...

Kind of hard to remember who I wanted at the time without obviously being biased one way or another depending on how they panned out.

Two that clearly stand out in my mind was Manny Lawson last year over Jason Allen, jury is still out on that one. The other was Drew Brees over Fletcher, that one ruined my day.


And for everyone bashing JP Losman, look at his stats from the last half of the season last year and tell me you wouldn't want him as our starting QB next year.

musphinzfan
04-07-2007, 02:10 PM
Theres so much crap i woulda done different for this team...It would take the whole day to come with all the bad FA's signing,Bad/Terrible drafts and some trades too.

jason8er
04-07-2007, 02:32 PM
Maybe it had something to do with those 8 beers...

Kind of hard to remember who I wanted at the time without obviously being biased one way or another depending on how they panned out.

Two that clearly stand out in my mind was Manny Lawson last year over Jason Allen, jury is still out on that one. The other was Drew Brees over Fletcher, that one ruined my day.


And for everyone bashing JP Losman, look at his stats from the last half of the season last year and tell me you wouldn't want him as our starting QB next year.
Come on bro, that ruined more than just ONE day. :lol:

PhinsRDbest
04-07-2007, 03:10 PM
I'm just going to do the last 2 years because its easy to look back and find a player we didn't choose that was the pick of the round.
2005
1. Ronnie Brown
2. Khalif Barnes (I like Roth but at the time really wasn't a need and Barnes could have fixed are LT problem)
3. Channing Crowder (With Charlie Frye off the board I feel we made the right choice)
4. Travis Daniels(Really nobody I wanted bad so Daniels was a good pick)
5. Anthony Alabi (same as top)
7. Kevin Vickerson (7th round is a crapshoot)
2006
1. Antonio Cromartie
3. Ko Simpson(before the draft I was wanting to trade down and take him in the late 1st getting him in the 3rd would've been a steal buffalo get him in the 4th)
4. Toledo was a good pick
5. Manny Wright good pick
7. Rod Wright good pick
7. Fred Evans good pick
7. Stanley McClover
Oh and I would have given are 3rd this years for Ahmad Brooks.
The defense would look like this:

LE-Rod Wright, Kevin Vickerson
NT-Keith Traylor, Fred Evans
DT-Vonnie Holiday, Manny Wright
RE-Jason Taylor, Stanley McClover
LOLB-Ahmad Brooks
MLB-Zach Thomas, Derrick Pope
ROLB-Channing Crowder
CB-Antonio Cromartie
CB-Will Allen
FS-Ko Simpson
SS-Yeremiah Bell

Phinsdude
04-07-2007, 03:47 PM
2006
1 - Nick Mangold
2 - Marcus McNeil ( didn't trade for DC)
3 - Brodie Croyle
4 - Gabe Watson
5 - XXX (used for Manny Wright)
6 - XXX
7 - Marques Colston
7 - Rodrique Wright

2005
1 - Ronnie Brown
2 - Khalif Barnes
3 - Channing Crowder
4 - Kerry Rhodes
5 - Anttaj Hawthorne
6 - XXX
7 - Kevin Vickerson

2004
1 - Vince Wilfork
2 - XXX
3 - XXX
4 - Nat Dorsey
5 - Drew Carter
6 - Rex Hadnot
7 - Carlos Joseph
7 - Derrick Pope

2003
1 - XXX
2 - Anquan Boldin
3 - Derrick Dockery
3 - Angelo Crowell
4 - XXX
5 - Dan Koppen
5 - Langston Moore
6 - Cato June
6 - Siddeeq Shabazz
7 - Scott Shanle

2002
1 - XXX
2 - XXX
3 - Chris Hope
4 - Randy McMichael
5 - Verron Haynes
5 - Josh Shaw
6 - XXX
7 - David Givens

2001
1 - Drew Brees
2 - Chris Chambers
3 - Casey Rabach
4 -

Sorry, can't do it any more! After I saw Jamar Fletchers name I got too depressed to finish. Man, Miami has has some really bad, lousy drafts. Almost makes you want to go get sick or something. Maybe if I went outside and threw something agains't the side of the house I will feel better. Yukkk.....

Fletcher just signed with the Texans 2 years, 2.4 million, that's 1.2 per year. Amazing as it is, he has made over 15 million dollars in the NFL.

23EmilioVasquez
04-07-2007, 05:57 PM
What are we doing

Tupac Shakur
04-08-2007, 03:15 AM
I'll have a stab at re-doing the drafts and taking a guy that Miami could have/should have taken in the same general vicinity (no more than 10-15 picks lower than the guy they really took)

I'll go back to 2000:

2nd round: Laveranues Coles, WR
3rd: David Barrett, CB
4th: Clark Haggans, LB
5th: Dante Hall, KR/WR
6th: Tom Brady, QB :)
7th: Patrick Pass, FB

2001
1st: Reggie Wayne, WR
2nd: Shaun Rogers, DT
3rd: Reggie Hayward, DE
3rd: Jonas Jennings, T
5th: Patrick Chuckwurah, LB/DE
6th: Cedric Wilson, WR
6th: Ellis Wyms, DT
6th: David Martin, TE
6th: Jimmy Williams, CB/PR

2002
3rd: Brian Westbrook, RB
4th: Randy McMichael, TE
5th: Verron Haynes, RB
5th: Justin Hartwig, C
7th: Kevin Shaffer, T

2003
2nd: Osi Umenyiora, DE
3rd: Derrick Dockery, G
3rd: Chris Simms, QB
5th: Dan Koppen, C
5th: Tony Pashos, T
6th: Hanik Milligan, S
6th: David Tyree, WR
6th: Yeremiah Bell, S
7th: Scott Shanle, LB

2004
1st: Vince Wilfork, DT
4th: Jerrico Cotchery, WR
5th: Thomas Tapeh, FB
6th: Rex Hadnot, C/G
7th: Derrick Pope, LB
7th: Bobby McCray, DE

2005
1st: Ronnie Brown, RB
2nd: Matt Roth, DE
3rd: Channing Crowder, LB
4th: Travis Daniels, CB
5th: Anthony Alabi, T
7th: Reynaldo Hill, CB

2006
1st: Antonio Cromartie, CB
3rd: Anthony Smith, S
4th: Steven Gostkowski, K
7th: Fred Evans, DT
7th: Rodrique Wright, DT
7th: Dee Webb, CB

Based on just the drafts, the roster would be:

QB: Tom Brady, Chris Simms
RB: Ronnie Brown, Brian Westbrook, Verron Haynes
FB: Patrick Pass, Thomas Tapeh
WR: Laveranues Coles, Reggie Wayne, Jerrico Cotchery, Cedric Wilson, Dante Hall, David Tyree
TE: Randy McMichael, David Martin
T: Jonas Jennings, Kevin Shaffer, Tony Pashos, Anthony Alabi
G: Rex Hadnot, Derrick Dockery
C: Dan Koppen, Justin Hartwig
DE: Osi Umenyiora, Reggie Hayward, Matt Roth, Bobby McCray
DT: Vince Wilfork, Shaun Rogers, Ellis Wyms, Fred Evans, Rodrique Wright
LB: Clark Haggans, Channing Crowder, Scott Shanle, Patrick Chuckwurah, Derrick Pope
CB: Antonio Cromartie, David Barrett, Reynaldo Hill, Travis Daniels, Dee Webb, Jimmy Williams
S: Yeremiah Bell, Anthony Smith, Hanik Milligan
K: Steven Gostkowski

The best draft by far was Saban's first draft. It's sad that only McMichael, Hadnot, Pope, and Bell were the right decisions pre-Saban. Obviously, some positions are lacking, but overall this team would win a championship.

Regan21286
04-08-2007, 05:20 PM
I figure I'll give it a shot.

1997

#15-1st.Tarik Glenn-OT (A guy to replace Webb down the line)
#44-2nd.Sam Madison-CB (duh)
#73-3rd.Jason Taylor-DE (doy)
#92-3rd.Derrick Mason-WR (nice WR for Marino to have)
#93-3rd.Derrick Rodgers-LB (played decently for a while)
#96-3rd.Brent Smith-G (should've kept him longer)
#121-4th.Al Singleton-LB (decent STer who's still around, a testament to his abilities)
#149-5th.Ndukwe Kalu-DE (pivotal part of Eagles DL)
#157-5th.Al Harris-CB (inconsistent CB, but decent enough for an evolving D)
#166-6th.Itula Mili-TE (best value here)
#170-6th.Grady Jackson-NT (see above)
#173-6th.Marcus Spriggs-OT (we ended up with him anyways)
#177-6th.Ed Perry-TE (good long snapper for a while)
#203-7th.Jason Ferguson-NT (BPA here)

1998

#29-1st.Sam Cowart-LB (defensive stalwart)
#44-2nd.Pat Surtain-CB (duh)
#49-2nd.Ahman Green-RB (this guy helped take Favre to the Super Bowl, I'd rather see him take Marino to the Super Bowl)
#79-3rd.Hines Ward-WR (Super Bowl MVP must mean something)
#82-3rd.Brian Griese-QB (The guy we could groom to be Marino and Griese Sr.'s heir apparent)
#102-4th.Lorenzo Bromell-DE (Broke Manning's jaw, good enough here
#143-5th.Scott McGarrahan-SS (ended up with him anyways)
#171-6th.Fred Beasley-FB (Pro Bowl FB for a while
#172-6th.Matt Birk-C (needs no explanation here)
#210-7th.Pat Tillman-SS (National Hero)

1999

#39-2nd.Dre Bly-CB (solidifies the CB spot)
#43-2nd.Joey Porter-LB (Another LB)
#72-3rd.Zach Piller-OG (would've been nice OL depth)
#142-4th.David Bowens-DE (did his job, which is enough)
#192-6th.Donald Driver-WR (Good 1st WR, Great 2nd WR, phenomenal 3rd WR)
#232-7th.Jermaine Haley-DT (Decent player)

2000

#53-2nd.Todd Wade-OT (Solid RT)
#84-3rd.Jeff Ulbrich-LB (Another good LB)
#117-4th.Shane Lechler-P (Beats Turk)
#152-5th.Ernest Grant-DT (Good DT)
#167-6th.Marc Bulger-QB (good depth at QB)
#232-7th.Patrick Pass-FB (does the little things at FB)

2001

#26-1st.Todd Heap-TE (Stud TE to be a good threat)
#52-2nd.Chris Chambers-WR (Good slot WR)
#85-3rd.Reggie Hayward-DE (Defensive stalwart for the Jags)
#88-3rd.Rudi Johnson-RB (Finally a solid RB who could've eased out injury prone Green)
#156-5th.Jonathan Carter-WR (Had potential but was lost in the muddled Blue)
#164-6th.Jason Glenn-LB (Solid STer)
#177-6th.Marlon McCree-FS (Iffy at times, but a good safety)
#187-6th.Terdell Sands-DT (late bloomer would've made practice squad)
#188-6th.Tupe Peko-OG (Probable practice team guy)

2002

#90-3rd.Brian Westbrook-RB (A guy to help Johnson out)
#114-4th.Randy McMichael-TE
#160-5th.Verron Haynes-RB (change of pace back)
#170-6th.Justin Hartwig-C (a decent C)
#241-7th.Kyle Kosier- G (versatile backup guard)

2003

#49-2nd.Anquan Boldin-WR (duh)
#78-3rd.Derrick Dockery-G (got a big payday this offseason)
#87-3rd.Chris Brown-RB (good RB depth)
#156-5th.Dan Koppen-C (another decent C)
#169-5th.Tony Pashos-OT (fair OT depth)
#181-6th.Corey Jenkins-LB (played ok for us)
#209-6th.David Tyree-WR (sleeper WR back then and ok performance)
#213-6th.Yeremiah Bell-SS (top playmaker in the secondary for us this year becomes our cheap backup)
#248-7th.Antwoine Sanders-CB (flyer on a prospect at CB)

2004

#19-1st.Vernon Carey-OT (solid RT who would replace Wade at this time)
#102-4th.Nathan Vasher-CB (good CB)
#160-5th.Will Poole-CB (project CB)
#174-6th.Rex Hadnot-G (nice backup for OG and C spots)
#221-7th.Donnie Jones-P (very good punter)
#222-7th.Derrick Pope-LB (filled in nicely as a backup)

2005 (hardly any change to the top 4)

#2-1st.Ronnie Brown-RB
#46-2nd.Matt Roth-DE
#70-3rd.Channing Crowder-LB
#104-4th.Travis Daniels-CB
#162-5th.Wesley Britt-OT (Is more productive than Alabi right now)
#216-7th.Reynaldo Hill-CB (Nice guy for a nickel-dime corner)

2006

#16-1st.Marcus McNeill-OT (who I wanted last year)
#48-2nd.Maurice Jones-Drew-RB (Would've been a nice PR/KR)
#82-3rd.Derek Hagan-WR (Still has potential)
#114-4th.Joe Toledo-OG (see above)
#212-7th.Fred Evans-DT (see above)
#226-7th.Rod Wright-DT (see above)
#233-7th. Devin Aromashodu-WR (see above)

crumpdaddy
04-08-2007, 09:14 PM
i give you guys credit who did the entire draft, i was too lazy so only did first 3 rounds. im on the draft aundrae allison bandwagon this year so 10 years from now if i get drunk and do this again yall will see he is the 3rd round pick. 3 weeks and counting til our BPA of the future

happy easter everyone:)