PDA

View Full Version : Whatcha Think?



Orange FinFan
04-10-2007, 01:01 PM
What do u guys think of this one? I dont think its that bad for my second one.


9th Levi Brown OT Penn State
40th Justin Harrell DT Tennesse
60th Jason Hill WR W. State
71st Kevin Kolb QB Houston
108th Tim Shaw LB Penn State
181st Tim Duckworth G Auburn
199th Kevin Boss TE W. Oregon
219th Courtney Brown CB Cal Poly
238th Allen Barbre T/G Missouri Southern

MD20
04-10-2007, 01:45 PM
We have young defensive tackles........................WE NEED CORNERBACKS!

MrClean
04-10-2007, 02:06 PM
What do u guys think of this one? I dont think its that bad for my second one.


9th Levi Brown OT Penn State
40th Justin Harrell DT Tennesse
60th Jason Hill WR W. State
71st Kevin Kolb QB Houston
108th Tim Shaw LB Penn State
181st Tim Duckworth G Auburn
199th Kevin Boss TE W. Oregon
219th Courtney Brown CB Cal Poly
238th Allen Barbre T/G Missouri Southern

IMO, you made some very good choices.
Tim Shaw is rated a 2-3 rounder, Courtney Brown is rated a 3-4 rounder, Allan Barbre is rated a 3-4 rounder, as is Kevin Boss. Duckworth is rated a 4-5 rounder. Justin Harrell is also rated a late 1st rounder, so will probably be gone by #40.
I took those rating from www.nfldraftscout.com since they are probably the most credible online only draft information source.
Since I mentioned OURLADS in another recent post, though they give more info in print form, I looked at how they rated your mock draftees, and according to how they rate those players, they would all be available, very likely, where you have them, except perhaps Barbre.
Looking at just those two sources, at this time, it shows how after one gets past the 1st round there is a great deal of inconsistency from source to source.

IF, the draft played out that way, very few would be able to complain IMO.

Orange FinFan
04-10-2007, 03:08 PM
IMO, you made some very good choices.
Tim Shaw is rated a 2-3 rounder, Courtney Brown is rated a 3-4 rounder, Allan Barbre is rated a 3-4 rounder, as is Kevin Boss. Duckworth is rated a 4-5 rounder. Justin Harrell is also rated a late 1st rounder, so will probably be gone by #40.
I took those rating from www.nfldraftscout.com since they are probably the most credible online only draft information source.
Since I mentioned OURLADS in another recent post, though they give more info in print form, I looked at how they rated your mock draftees, and according to how they rate those players, they would all be available, very likely, where you have them, except perhaps Barbre.
Looking at just those two sources, at this time, it shows how after one gets past the 1st round there is a great deal of inconsistency from source to source.

IF, the draft played out that way, very few would be able to complain IMO.

I having been using the USA TODAY draft guide for my reference. Thank you though for the feedback. I wish it would work out this way as well.

GMP-AGAIN
04-10-2007, 11:05 PM
We have young defensive tackles........................WE NEED CORNERBACKS!

I agree. We can gradually get linebackers and defensive linemen to replace those who are aging but the Fins need DB's NOW. DB's who will run, who will be super-aggressive, and who will break up those passes 9.9 times out of 10!

Phanatical
04-10-2007, 11:25 PM
What do u guys think of this one? I dont think its that bad for my second one.


9th Levi Brown OT Penn State
40th Justin Harrell DT Tennesse
60th Jason Hill WR W. State
71st Kevin Kolb QB Houston
108th Tim Shaw LB Penn State
181st Tim Duckworth G Auburn
199th Kevin Boss TE W. Oregon
219th Courtney Brown CB Cal Poly
238th Allen Barbre T/G Missouri Southern

I like your picks but I can tell you one thing, there is no way in on god's green earth that Brown will last til 219 or Barbre will last til 238 (IMO Barbre is probably the third best LT in this draft). The Phins also have to get some depth at DE which your draft neglects. I like my mock much better in the first rounds and I have some realistic picks in the later rounds, plus my mock get us two quality DE's (NOTE: Barbre would be my obvious pick at 199 instead of Hall IF he's still on the boards and Brown would be my pick at 219 instead of Anam if he's still on the boards but I don't think either will be).

GO PHINS~!