PDA

View Full Version : U-RANK the Offensive Linemen



Paul 13
04-17-2007, 11:59 PM
This is always a little difficult because you have tackles projected as guards, center/guard combos, etc etc... So, I'll break them out by T / G / C all in the same thread.

OT:
1. Joe Thomas
2. Levi Brown
3. Joe Staley
4. Doug Free
5. James Marten
6. Tony Ugoh
7. Ryan Harris
8. Mike Otto
9. Allen Barbre
10. Adam Koets

OG:
1. Justin Blalock
2. Ben Grubbs
3. Aaron Sears
4. Manuel Ramirez
5. Andy Alleman
6. Tim Duckworth
7. Dan Santucci
8. Mansfield Wrotto
9. Cameron Stephenson
10. Kasey Stoddard

C:
1. Josh Beekman
2. Ryan Kalil
3. Samson Satele
4. Leroy Harris
5. Doug Datish

MastR_EvaluatoR
04-18-2007, 12:11 AM
C:
1. Josh Beekman
2. Ryan Kalil
3. Samson Satele
4. Leroy Harris
5. Doug Datish

Why do you have Beekman so high ? He is widely considered as the 3rd best center in the draft way behind Kalil, and behind Satele as well ..

Ozzy
04-18-2007, 01:12 AM
Why do you have Beekman so high ? He is widely considered as the 3rd best center in the draft way behind Kalil, and behind Satele as well ..


Oh really? First of all plenty have both listed as Gaurds not Centers, and plenty of sites top 100 have Beekman just ahead of Satele.

Paul 13
04-18-2007, 01:21 AM
Why do you have Beekman so high ? He is widely considered as the 3rd best center in the draft way behind Kalil, and behind Satele as well ..

Understood, they are closer than that IMO. I like Beekman's bulk/strength/drive blocking ability over Kalil and Satele. I also like his versatility to be able to play guard if needed. Kalil is a center only, needs to bulk up or he'll be tossed around by the likes of the AFC East NT's. Satele is okay, but not as strong as Beekman.

Aqua4Ever04
04-18-2007, 02:38 AM
I'm not informed well enough to go 10 deep at these positions, so let's just go 10 best lineman reguardless of position.

1. OT Joe Thomas
2. C Ryan Kalil
3. OT Levi Brown
4. OT Joe Staley
5. OG Ben Grubbs
6. OT Tony Ugoh
7. OG Justin Blaylock
8. OT Doug Free
9. OG Aaron Sears
10. OT Ryan Harris

MrClean
04-18-2007, 03:06 AM
OT:
1. Joe Thomas
2. Joe Staley
3. Levi Brown
4. Doug Free
5. Jermon Bushrod
6. James Marten
7. Ryan Harris
8. Adam Koets
9. Mario Henderson
10. Jacob Bender

OG:
1. Ben Grubbs
2. Justin Blalock
3. Arron Sears
4. Josh Beekman
5. Andy Alleman
6. Manuel Ramirez
7. Marshal Yanda
8. Mike Jones
9. Dan Santucci
10. Allen Barbre

OC:
1. Ryan Kalil
2. Samson Satele
3. Doug Datish
4. Drew Mormino
5. Leroy Harris
6. Enoka Lucas
7. Dustin Fry
8. Dan Mozes
9. Scott Stephenson
10. Mike Elgin

Regan21286
04-18-2007, 03:23 AM
OT:
1.Joe Thomas
2.Joe Staley
3.Levi Brown
4.Arron Sears
5.Doug Free
6.Tony Ugoh
7.James Marten
8.Ryan Harris
9.Dane Uperesa
10.Julius Wilson

OG:
1.Justin Blalock
2.Ben Grubbs
3.Josh Beekman
4.Manuel Ramirez
5.Andy Alleman
6.Marshall Yanda
7.Cameron Stephenson
8.Uche Nwaneri
9.Tim Duckworth
10.Mansfield Wrotto

C:
1.Ryan Kalil
2.Samson Satele
3.Doug Datish
4.Leroy Harris
5.Dan Mozes
6.Dustin Fry
7.Enoka Lucas
8.Nick Jones
9.Kyle Young
10.Drew Mormino

Phanatical
04-18-2007, 05:01 AM
This is always a little difficult because you have tackles projected as guards, center/guard combos, etc etc... So, I'll break them out by T / G / C all in the same thread.

OT:
1. Joe Thomas
2. Levi Brown
3. Joe Staley
4. Doug Free
5. James Marten
6. Tony Ugoh
7. Ryan Harris
8. Mike Otto
9. Allen Barbre
10. Adam Koets



I'm only going to rank the tackles, as this is the Phins biggest need. The C spot is very weak in this draft IMO and the Phins aren't really in need of a guard, so I've not looked at that position at all.

OT:
1. Joe Thomas
2. Levi Brown
3. Joe Staley
4. Doug Free
5. Tony Ugoh
6. Allen Barbre
7. Marshall Yanda
8. James Marten
9. Ryan Harris
10. Mike Otto

Jaj
04-18-2007, 05:14 AM
I'd say we're just as in need of a guard as we are a tackle. Toledo and Monica are no guarantee at LG.

A hole at LT is worse than one at LG but still we saw what a hole at even RG could do to you early on last year.

finfan54
04-18-2007, 06:19 AM
No way, no how is Joe Staley the number 2 LT.

Wade Smith waiting to happen and he cannot or will not start right away and if he does, people will see that he is not starting material at LT yet. He needs to put more bulk/weight on. Like alabi had to. Better upside than alabi however.