View Full Version : Draft Grade

04-26-2009, 07:16 PM
I going to grade by selection:

Vontae Davis A+ ability, D+ attitude = B-
Pat White = C serious doubts about his ability to stay healthy, has the ability to play
Sean Smith = A great value, quality player
Pat Turner = B solid player, maybe a little overvalued
Brian Hartline = D good player but there were better players that would fit our team, picked too high, plays the same postion as other proven players on the team, pick made no sense
John Nalbone = ? Can not grade because honestly do not know anything
about him
Chris Clemons = B+ solid safety and good value with the pick
Andew Gardner = C average OL, has trouble sustaining blocks, has trouble with speed off the edge, better value with if this pick was a round later
J D Folsom = F The main reson for this grade is because this guy could have been picked up in FA, there is no value in this pick when there are other players available
our last pick was traded to the Chiefs do not know what for

B-(+)C(+)A(+)B(+)D(+)B+(+)C(+)F= Final Grade C-

04-26-2009, 07:29 PM
your thread: F-

04-26-2009, 07:37 PM
im wit you on that DKfin.....time will tell..

04-26-2009, 07:48 PM
definitely an F for dkfin for being a gator fan

04-26-2009, 07:52 PM
You gave an 'F' to a 7th round pick? lol.

04-26-2009, 08:00 PM
C+ only because we got jumped for Barden by the Giants and the GT NT in the seventh by the gaytriots.

B+ if we got the guys we wanted. I also felt Folsom would have gone undrafted and we could have gotten the NT and him.

04-26-2009, 08:42 PM
Its something to the fact that teams seemed to jump us... Is the regime that predictable? And that in line with certain types of players? I think so and it may speak to an old why of play on the field, that only time will tell if it brings us a champion or just another "good" team.

Aside from that I like CB Sean Smith, WR Pat Turner and TE Nalbone (SP) but with the TE, I was hoping we got a more explosive player at the position. And DT Scott being gone as well as DT Brace took the Dolphins into different directions that in the end, landed us with 3WRs on a team that barely dresses 4 WRs on game day. At least they stayed true to their board.