PDA

View Full Version : Best WR in the league



PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 09:43 AM
Who is the best WR in the league?
Andre Johnson?
Steve Smith?
Calvin Johnson?
Larry Fitz?
Randy Moss?
Or
Someone else?

TedSlimmJr
07-08-2009, 10:07 AM
I'd have to say Andre Johnson....and not just based off numbers either....he's incredible to watch abuse defensive backs....he produces without the caliber of quarterback that Fitz has IMO....

Calvin Johnson has the potential to be the best on that list one day....but that depends on Matthew Stafford....

They're all pretty damn scary....including Reggie Wayne...

ArmyFin7
07-08-2009, 10:37 AM
I would say there is the Johnsons, then fitz....then there is everyone else, but the dropoff fter fitz is pretty steep.

Farmer
07-08-2009, 11:48 AM
i wouldnt put Calvin Johnson in the same group as Fitz and AJ yet, but he could be there.

Fitz then AJ for me though

SpaceMountain16
07-08-2009, 01:28 PM
Larry Fitzgerald who pretty much carried the Cardinals to the Super Bowl last season. When you're so good on a big stage you earn the right to be called the best in football.

:-)
07-08-2009, 03:37 PM
If I were a head coach I would take Larry Fitzgerald before anyone.

WISfinfan13
07-08-2009, 03:40 PM
Larry Fitzgerald hands down.

:-)
07-08-2009, 03:57 PM
I wanted them to win so bad last year.

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d80e88310/Larry-Fitzgerald-Highlight-WK-22-vs-Steelers-2008

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 05:16 PM
Number #1 for me is fitz.
Every time anyone posts a reply copy and paste this into your reply and add your own vote to the ( ).
Here is an example.
Count so far:
1. (enter name of who has the most votes ex. Bob Williamson, DONT put the player in the ( ). ) (Now enter the amount of votes the person has ex. 4 votes)

Now is the actual thing.
1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (2 total votes)
3. Steve Smith (0 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (0 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (0 total votes)
3. Somebody Else (0 total votes

cafinfan408
07-08-2009, 05:33 PM
1 or 2 more years and its Calvin almost no contest.
2-3 years ago it would of been Moss
But as of right now its a toss up between Fitz and AJ and they both served us last year.
I gotta give it to Andre though

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 06:35 PM
So then
1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (3 total votes)
3. Steve Smith (0 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (0 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (0 total votes)
3. Somebody Else (0 total votes)
Remember to do this guys.

#1dolphinsfan
07-08-2009, 06:35 PM
andre Johnson is the best IMO he just isnt as flashy as Fitz

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 06:41 PM
1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (4 total votes)
3. Steve Smith (0 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (0 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (0 total votes)
3. Somebody Else (0 total votes)

You guys really have to remember to copy and paste this into all your comments!
Just add 1 total vote to whoever you think is the best wr in the league

Clipse
07-08-2009, 06:43 PM
Calvin Johnson. Andre Johnson and Fitzgerald are very close seconds, but they both have good QB's throwing them the ball. If C. Johnson gets a decent QB throwing him the ball, he will be an absolute beast. Put it this way, if all three were free agents right now and I had a choice, I'm taking C. Johnson, his potential to be one of the best ever is very high.

TBW12
07-08-2009, 06:48 PM
1 or 2 more years and its Calvin almost no contest.
2-3 years ago it would of been Moss
But as of right now its a toss up between Fitz and AJ and they both served us last year.
I gotta give it to Andre though

2-3 years ago Moss wouldn't even be in the discussion. Lets remember, Randy Moss is just one season removed from catching 23 regular season touchdowns. I like Calvin Johnson's potential and I think Andre Johnson is very good, but I don't think either is of Randy Moss' caliber at this moment. If Calvin had Tom Brady to him would I change my opinion? Maybe, but I'm just going off of right now. Plus Calvin's just entering his 3rd season so I'm not ready to put him ahead of Moss.

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 06:54 PM
PEOPLE, when you post copy this into your comment. Don't make it harder for me.
1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (4 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (1 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (1 total votes)
4. Somebody Else (0 total votes)
4. Steve Smith (0 total votes)

TBW12
07-08-2009, 06:57 PM
1. Randy Moss (25 total votes)
2. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
3. Andre Johnson (4 total votes)
4. Calvin Johnson (1 total votes)
5. Somebody Else (0 total votes)
6. Steve Smith (0 total votes)

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 07:02 PM
If you take 24 votes away from moss then you're the first person to do it the way I want.
Congrats.

X-Pacolypse
07-08-2009, 08:30 PM
Hands down. Larry Fitzgerald.

kud
07-08-2009, 09:14 PM
PEOPLE, when you post copy this into your comment. Don't make it harder for me.
1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (5 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (1 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (1 total votes)
4. Somebody Else (0 total votes)
4. Steve Smith (0 total votes)

Wouldn't it have been easier to just create a poll. :up:

I'll vote for AJ since he's behind they(he and Fitz) are the two best right now imo, too close to call.

1. Larry Fitzgerald (5 total votes)
2. Andre Johnson (5 total votes)
3. Randy Moss (1 total votes)
3. Calvin Johnson (1 total votes)
4. Somebody Else (0 total votes)
4. Steve Smith (0 total votes)

RaboGrande24
07-08-2009, 09:27 PM
1a. Andre Johnson 1b. Larry Fitzgerald

PhinPhan910
07-08-2009, 09:46 PM
So this is what it looks like now:
1.Larry Fitzgerald (6)
2. Andre Johnson (5)
3.Calvin Johnson (1)
3.Randy moss (1)
5.Steve Smith (0)
5.Somone Else (0)

Oh, and for CHI, I was pressured to go somewhere really fast and i didn't have enough time to make a poll and I dont think you can edit in a poll.

cafinfan408
07-08-2009, 10:04 PM
2-3 years ago Moss wouldn't even be in the discussion. Lets remember, Randy Moss is just one season removed from catching 23 regular season touchdowns. I like Calvin Johnson's potential and I think Andre Johnson is very good, but I don't think either is of Randy Moss' caliber at this moment. If Calvin had Tom Brady to him would I change my opinion? Maybe, but I'm just going off of right now. Plus Calvin's just entering his 3rd season so I'm not ready to put him ahead of Moss.

Actually that is 2 seasons ago now. So yea i stick to my answer 2-3 years ago it would be him.

TBW12
07-09-2009, 02:01 AM
Actually that is 2 seasons ago now. So yea i stick to my answer 2-3 years ago it would be him.


At the end of this season it will be 2 seasons ago. Only one season has passed since he broke the NFL record for TD catches in a season. One season since FinHeaven LOL'd at the Patriots trading for him saying it was out of "desperation" and that Cam Cameron and John Beck were the future and we'd all be jealous of the John Beck to Ted Ginn HOF Duo.

cafinfan408
07-09-2009, 06:36 AM
Well i am sorry.
it wasnt last year so to me its 2 years ago

chibully
07-09-2009, 02:16 PM
so where does Wes Welker rank? He's pretty underrated I guess, maybe not but I haven't really heard his name mentioned when talking about the best recievers? He's kinda like that guy you don't really think, he kinda quietly caught like 112 passes last year.

TBW12
07-09-2009, 03:13 PM
so where does Wes Welker rank? He's pretty underrated I guess, maybe not but I haven't really heard his name mentioned when talking about the best recievers? He's kinda like that guy you don't really think, he kinda quietly caught like 112 passes last year.


He's great. 112 catches the last two years. Having said that, he's not in the league of a Moss, Fitzgerald, A/C Johnson. Those guys are physical freaks.

BobDole
07-09-2009, 04:52 PM
i'd say larry fitzgerald - but if i could pick one out of the bunch to be on my team it would be calvin johnson. AJ's great but he's hurt too much.

PhinPhan910
07-09-2009, 08:46 PM
So this is what it looks like now:
1.Larry Fitzgerald (7)
2. Andre Johnson (5)
3.Calvin Johnson (1)
3.Randy moss (1)
5.Steve Smith (0)
5.Somone Else (0)

I would have expected some love for steve smith, but i guess not.

emeraldfin
07-09-2009, 08:48 PM
Andre Johnson

The guy is the most dominant WR in the league.

Charlie Brown
07-10-2009, 12:41 AM
Not being a homer or anything but Steve Smith is pound for pound the best WR in the NFL....hes 5'9" and he goes up and gets the ball like hes 6'5".....Not to mention he is a tough SOB, he breaks more tackels than anyone else on that list

TBW12
07-10-2009, 02:36 AM
Not being a homer or anything but Steve Smith is pound for pound the best WR in the NFL....hes 5'9" and he goes up and gets the ball like hes 6'5".....Not to mention he is a tough SOB, he breaks more tackels than anyone else on that list


I agree

:napoleon:

BARF
07-10-2009, 04:39 AM
i would have to say steve smith, he does everything better overall screens, yac, goes deep, and he is strong as hell, not as strong as fitz, or aj, but he is definitely a better playmaker

PhinPhan910
07-10-2009, 10:59 AM
So this is what it looks like now:
1.Larry Fitzgerald (7)
2. Andre Johnson (6)
3.Steve Smith (2)
4.Calvin Johnson (1)
4.Randy moss (1)
5.Somone Else (0)