PDA

View Full Version : Henne, Pennington or Thigpen, who woul you go with....?



dolphans1
08-22-2010, 11:15 AM
Boy oh boy, what depth at quarterback.....,

A few years ago we didn't have a quarterback, now we have 3 potential starters.

Problem is, who would you seriously go with ....?

I'm leaning toward Thigpen, I am really impressed by his play last season, and what I saw when he played last year with us, and with the Chiefs, he looked really impressive.

Do you think we'll carry all 3.....?

Also, is Pat White still on this team...?

d-1

Vaark
08-22-2010, 11:19 AM
yeah, I'd keep Thiggy over White just in case our b/up Penny's China Doll body doesn't hold up.

(oh, and if you're asking who should start, "Shirley you jest.")

XxfeensterxX
08-22-2010, 11:20 AM
So wait, your saying you would rather have Thigpen start then Henne?

Hell no.

mia4ever
08-22-2010, 11:22 AM
Henne hands down ..
Penny pass to BM was a lame duck ,and Marshall made a great play on it ..

I like Thigpen gunslinger mentality ,but the kid need to check down more..
Henne is just what we need ..

BM being a diva wide-out will place pressure on Henne to play well...

Cloudy
08-22-2010, 11:25 AM
In all honesty and I might catch some flak for this but my order goes like this...

Pennington-Henne-Thigpen.

The way Pennington took over that season and took us to 11-5 while getting revenge over the Jets in the last week of the season was awe-inspiring. We started off slow the next year and he went down for the season. Crappy way to end a career. I think he can still start and be pretty solid.

Henne has been great for us so far and I think he's ready to lead a team without question. I'm just a Pennington homer.

X-Pacolypse
08-22-2010, 11:26 AM
1. Chad Henne

2. Chad Pennington

3. Tyler Thigpen

RobertHorry
08-22-2010, 11:26 AM
Thigen is NOT starter material. He is barely average, if that.

studsatele
08-22-2010, 11:27 AM
Henne. Penny is Glass Joe from punchout and Thiggy isnt even close to the qb that Penny is.

dolphans1
08-22-2010, 11:28 AM
I like Thigpen's mobility and versatility, he's able to move the ball down the field...., I'm leaning toward the Thigpen camp, however, I feel all 3 could do the job....and start in this league.

d-1

xxdolfanxx
08-22-2010, 11:29 AM
This is rediculous! Henne is the man. There is no way he doesn't start. He look awesome last night. Its his TEAM!

Pennington10
08-22-2010, 11:32 AM
Henne, but if he for whatever reason doesn't do well, than I'd start wanting Pennington back out there.

X-Pacolypse
08-22-2010, 11:33 AM
Henne. Penny is Glass Joe from punchout and Thiggy isnt even close to the qb that Penny is.

No, that would be Jake Grove.

mia4ever
08-22-2010, 11:33 AM
This is rediculous! Henne is the man. There is no way he doesn't start. He look awesome last night. Its his TEAM!

man I agree..
Show Henne some luv....folks.

flynryan15
08-22-2010, 11:33 AM
Marshall a Diva WR are you nuts? Diva's don't give up their bodies to throw blocks down field like Marshall does! He is the reason both Ronnie and Fassano scored. Wanting the football doesn't make home a Diva! It makes him a player maker! He is an elite WR you feed him the ball and let him punish the Defense! A Diva that will put pressure on Henne? Give me a friggen break every QB dreams of a monster like Marshall to throw too! Pressure on Henne? Give me a break! He has a new toy that he knows will dominate a CB and go up and get the ball. That's not pressure that's comfort!

DphinBillkiller
08-22-2010, 11:33 AM
1. Chad Henne

2. Chad Pennington

3. Tyler Thigpen

RobertHorry
08-22-2010, 11:35 AM
I like Thigpen's mobility and versatility, he's able to move the ball down the field...., I'm leaning toward the Thigpen camp, however, I feel all 3 could do the job....and start in this league.

d-1

Seriously, what are you guys watching? Thigpen didnt move the ball downfield. His dump off passes did. Thigpen couldn't score 3 times inside the opponents 20 against a 2nd/3rd team defense. That should say enough.

PhinsPhan11
08-22-2010, 11:35 AM
It should go Henne, Penny, Thigpen.

Kdawg954
08-22-2010, 11:39 AM
Is this thread for real?

I can understand the Thigpen over White, that is obvious. I can even understand people still not wanting Noodle arm in there and putting Thigpen over Pennington (as crazy as that sounds) but we have people wanting Thigpen over Henne? LMAO. I guess if the Fins let Thigpen start against the Duke BlueDevils football team and he racked up 5 TD's and 400 yards while Henne has 150 1 TD and 3 INT against any starting NFL defense, we would see the cut Henne threads and start Thigpen stuff. It is PRESEASON people. Give any defensive coordinator a week to gameplan against Thigpen and there is a good chance the guy gets shut down. These coaches watch these guys all the time.

And besides that, I didn't think Thigpen was all of that last night . . . definitely a better spread QB over a pro passer. Love the fact that he has experience, and he isn't a bad injury option if Henne went down, but this is definitely Chad Henne's team right now.

mia4ever
08-22-2010, 11:50 AM
Marshall a Diva WR are you nuts? Diva's don't give up their bodies to throw blocks down field like Marshall does! He is the reason both Ronnie and Fassano scored. Wanting the football doesn't make home a Diva! It makes him a player maker! He is an elite WR you feed him the ball and let him punish the Defense! A Diva that will put pressure on Henne? Give me a friggen break every QB dreams of a monster like Marshall to throw too! Pressure on Henne? Give me a break! He has a new toy that he knows will dominate a CB and go up and get the ball. That's not pressure that's comfort!

oh calm down
I meant it in a good way...

Batroc
08-22-2010, 12:06 PM
Henne - Pennington - Thigpen. There should be no question.

flynryan15
08-22-2010, 12:07 PM
oh calm down
I meant it in a good way...

Sorry that term just pisses me off! Ginn is a Diva! He is a self centered little prick who won't sacrifice his body for the team.

Marshall is the ultimate team WR! He bust his *** in practice, but more important sacrifices his body in the game! For every catch, for every extra inch after the catch, and down field blocking. If Marshall is calling for the ball it is because he is open and when a guy has 3 straight 100 rec seasons, breaks the single game rec record w/ 18 then breaks it again w/ 21 a few games later you feed him the ball.

Scott Andrew
08-22-2010, 12:09 PM
Weird thread... I think Dolphans1 might be related to Thigpen, no offense but Thigpen is no-where near Pennington or Henne

Goin` Deep
08-22-2010, 12:16 PM
Weird thread is right! Henne will be this teams starting QB for the next ten years. He has all the tools of being a great one. After him, I`d go with Pennington 2# and Tyler as the 3. Thigpen had his moments at the end of last year, but I don`t see him winning the backup spot on this team.

flynryan15
08-22-2010, 12:21 PM
It's pretty simple Thigpen has trade value, Tuna likes draft picks!

mia4ever
08-22-2010, 12:25 PM
Sorry that term just pisses me off! Ginn is a Diva! He is a self centered little prick who won't sacrifice his body for the team.

Marshall is the ultimate team WR! He bust his *** in practice, but more important sacrifices his body in the game! For every catch, for every extra inch after the catch, and down field blocking. If Marshall is calling for the ball it is because he is open and when a guy has 3 straight 100 rec seasons, breaks the single game rec record w/ 18 then breaks it again w/ 21 a few games later you feed him the ball.


I concur 100%
I so Happy we have a WR who want the ball

Not some1 why (ted Ginn)shy away for it....

ps marlon moore is better than Ted..

flynryan15
08-22-2010, 12:30 PM
I concur 100%
I so Happy we have a WR who want the ball

Not some1 why (ted Ginn)shy away for it....

ps marlon moore is better than Ted..

Half of our cheerleaders would fight for the ball and YAC better then Ginn!

I don't get to excited about undrafted players or low round picks in preseason. I'm sure after last week everyone on here was wanting to trade for Victor Cruz after he torched the Jets for 150yds and 3tds. Well this week he got to play with 2nd stringers and look like a udfa.

DavePornstache
08-22-2010, 12:33 PM
Boy oh boy, what depth at quarterback.....,

A few years ago we didn't have a quarterback, now we have 3 potential starters.

Problem is, who would you seriously go with ....?

I'm leaning toward Thigpen, I am really impressed by his play last season, and what I saw when he played last year with us, and with the Chiefs, he looked really impressive.

Do you think we'll carry all 3.....?

Also, is Pat White still on this team...?

d-1


Oh dear god, Dolphans1 aka D-1....... one of the reasons I left the armpit that is DolphinDigest.

Good times ahead when he/she/it start rattling off nonsense. I'm sure Hooshoops will concur.

Adam First
08-22-2010, 12:44 PM
I'm a Thigpen fan, I think he's worthy of the #3. Deserves it alot more than Pat White.

Henne/Pennington/Thigpen

HurriPhin
08-22-2010, 12:48 PM
Is this post seriously asking who starts or just which QB's make the final roster?

In any case it's
1. Henne
2. Henne
3. Henne

DavePornstache
08-22-2010, 12:49 PM
I'm a Thigpen fan, I think he's worthy of the #3. Deserves it alot more than Pat White.

Henne/Pennington/Thigpen

Better then Pat White...Yes

A Starting NFL Quarterback.....No

Henne/Penne/Thiggy

PhinsPhan11
08-23-2010, 04:48 PM
Henne - Pennington - Thigpen. There should be no question.
I agree, no question.

hooshoops
08-23-2010, 04:54 PM
i'm going with henne...all the way...he's the only one who gives us a shot to win the big one...

fatkirstyalley
08-23-2010, 05:01 PM
Uh. Henne

TropicalSwarm13
08-23-2010, 05:23 PM
Is this a joke??

emeraldfin
08-23-2010, 06:59 PM
Henne, without question.

Clipse
08-23-2010, 07:07 PM
There's no question here, it's obviously Henne. Thigpen blows.

kbeath
08-23-2010, 08:00 PM
This is really simple it is Henne, Pennington,......................................Thigpen. Not even close people....Some of you really blow my mind. Henne threw 1 bad ball in the whole time he played the other night...Lets be real.

Flip Tanneflop
08-23-2010, 10:57 PM
Why do some of you actually post in a ****ing thread like this????????

WTF!!

All that was needed to post(and if I had it I would) is that thing from the Simpsons that JCane posted in another thread where the dude walks in the room and walks back out. Thats it.

You guys are seriously debating who should be the starting QB and the OP claims Thigpen. Why is this thread even in the depths? This is :spam: