PDA

View Full Version : trade opinion



Daytona Fin
09-17-2010, 07:18 PM
i have percy harvin and jahvid best this guy wants to trade me the giants steve smith and shiancoe for those two.

my other wrs are reggie wayne, desean jackson and dez bryant. my other RBs are forte, jamaal charles,hightower and mcfadden. i have owens daniels as my TE but he seems to be off to a slow start with the injury, so i need a TE.

should i deal?

emeraldfin
09-18-2010, 04:20 PM
Its a good offer.

Smith is more so the Giants possession guy, will catch alot of balls, but will not get you alot of TD's, would be good to have in a PPR league. Shiancoe is Favre's favourite target right now and a great target in the endzone. Considering the problems Daniels is having at the moment he would be a major upgrade.

Harvin is struggling at the moment with injury and the Vikings dont seem to have much of a passing game at the moment. But he is still the Vikings only playmaker at receiver and their number 1 also. I'm a big fan of Best and with Stafford out I think the Lions will give him the rock even more now. I would have no problem dealing Harvin, but I would hate to be giving up Best.

But if your confident in your other RB's to get the job done for you, then trade.

CashInFist
09-18-2010, 06:24 PM
I'd take the deal if I were you.

Mako
09-22-2010, 11:13 AM
i have percy harvin and jahvid best this guy wants to trade me the giants steve smith and shiancoe for those two.

my other wrs are reggie wayne, desean jackson and dez bryant. my other RBs are forte, jamaal charles,hightower and mcfadden. i have owens daniels as my TE but he seems to be off to a slow start with the injury, so i need a TE.

should i deal?

Do it.

Smith is good for yards and should get you about 7-8 TD.

Shinacoe has a rappore with Favre, and Brett looks his way often.

Your HB are pretty solid all around, so you're not going to be hurting by trading Best and Harvin's migranes put him in question. Even as is, I think Smith is the better WR.

Your WR core now is good. Getting Smith makes them better.