PDA

View Full Version : Good Trade???



Miami 13
09-20-2004, 03:09 PM
I am in this yahoo Fantasy Football league, I know this kid and he wants Clinton Portis from me reall bad, is this a good trade? My Clinton Portis, Drew Bennett, and Jimmy Smith FOR Randy Moss, Joey Harrington and injured Stephen Davis. Good Trade or Not?

Jwcolour
09-20-2004, 03:21 PM
who are your other WR's, RB's and QB

InMyChambers
09-20-2004, 03:56 PM
RB's are gold in most fantasy leagues and you'd be taking a huuuuuuuuge hit there. not to mention stephen davis doesn't catch many passes. harrington is nothing special.

t2thejz
09-20-2004, 04:36 PM
Need to know your other RBs

Miami 13
09-20-2004, 07:22 PM
OK, this is my team:
QB-
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady (Might trade for Steve McNair)
Byron Leftwich
RB-
Clinton Portis
Kevin Barlow
Corey Dillon
Kevin Jones
WR-
Eric Moulds
Koren Robinson
Roy Williams
Drew Bennett
Jimmy Smith
TE-
Alge Crumpler
K-
Ryan Longwell
Defense-
Miami
Philadelphia

His Team-
QB-
Michael Vick
Jake Delhomme
Josh McCown
Joey Harrington
RB-
Quentin Griffin
Onterio Smith
Stephen Davis
WR-
Randy Moss
Chris Chambers
Rod Smith
Laverneas Coles
TE-
Jeremy Shockey
K-
John Kasay
Jeff Reed
Defense-
Tampa Bay
Seattle

TripleThreat
09-20-2004, 07:48 PM
NO WAY I do this trade you's be getting raped.

Moss is great
Harrington will stay on your bench
Davis can't play for a while and will be RBBC when he get's back.

He wants Portis he's gotta pony up. You have him over the barrell b/c soon Ont Smith will sit for 4 wks and Davis will be out...

Not sure why you would want to trade Portis, I wouldn't

Miami 13
09-20-2004, 08:23 PM
He just proposed this trade...Chris Chambers, Marty Booker, Vinny Testaverde, and Stephen Davis for Clinton Portis

TripleThreat
09-21-2004, 12:53 AM
Not sure why you would want to trade Portis, I wouldn'tRead again.

What's your Starting positions, points, etc...

Chambers is a WR1A
Booker shouldn't be starting
Vinny -how many QB's do you start?
Davis is hurt

You have him over the barrell only way I'd do it is maybe Randy Moss and Davis for Portis

Portis is a top 5 guy Moss #8 Davis 2nd Tier RB

But me I don't trade my stud RB. Never.