View Full Version : Dillon or McGahee???

08-03-2005, 03:40 PM
Which AFC East Rival would you choose?
Dillon or McGahee??

I am thinking Dillon... Both have great defenses... but Dillon has a better line and Tom Brady. Defenses cant stack the box near as much as they can against the Bills with Losman starting and the Bills line isnt near as good...
Dillon did also have 1600+ yards and 12 TDs last year...

BUT... The Pats do dumb sh!t like throwing the ball on 3rd and goal from the 1 to like Vrabil or something...

What do you guys think?


08-03-2005, 06:30 PM
Dillon would be the safest choice. There is little injury risk, and he will get a lot of carries. He can be marked for 1300 yards and 6-9 TD's.

However, the upside of Willis is too good to pass up. I picked him up last year for the final 4 games, and he literally carried my adverage team to the Finals, including a 4 TD game. He has an injury concern, and J.P. Losman is young, but his big play ability puts him as the #3 overall back on my board, behind only L.T. and Shaun. As Dillon is a sure first round runningback, Willis could have a 1800 total yard season with 12-15 touchdowns when all is said and done.

It depends on if you rather play it totally safe, or take a little risk.

Bit Willis is my man.