Darren Sproles or Reggie Bush

[NY8123]

Ok since the Dolphins forum is overrun with the "sky is falling" treads how about a good ol' fashion debate, one that is on a few websites this week.

Question: If you had your choice would you take Darren Sproles or Reggie Bush at running back?

I agree with Tony Dungy and I think I would have to go Sproles.

[dlockz]

I would go with Bush because he is an elite receiver plus a better return guy

[#1dolphinsfan]

sproles

[emeraldfin]

Even if he is going up against the Steelers, Sproules is far more consistant

[PhinPhan910]

Sproollllesssss

[Ricky_Fan34]

As previously mentioned, Sproles is much more consistant. Would definately go with him.

[Ricky4Life]

Sproles

[SpaceMountain16]

I would go with Bush because he is an elite receiver plus a better return guy

I don't know about being a better return guy. Sproles is an electric return man, he was at Michigan State anyway. I haven't really seen the Chargers use him in that role. Maybe they do, i'm not sure.

[Vertical Limit]

Running backs just never works out in New Orleans. Ricky Williams had the same issue, fumbling the ball a lot then got traded and his career started over again. I don't think they're using Bush correctly.

[SpaceMountain16]

Running backs just never works out in New Orleans. Ricky Williams had the same issue, fumbling the ball a lot then got traded and his career started over again. I don't think they're using Bush correctly.

Ricky was pretty solid with the Saints though when he played. He did have some injury issues which i think slowed him down, though i agree a change of scenery did help him revamp his career.

[NY8123]

I have to agree Sproles has shown more in is career then Bush so far. Bush reminded me of Cadillac coming out of a two back set.

While I brought up the two back set it is the same worry I had about Ronnie also. He is at least built larger and in my opinion better suited for the feature back roll.