Discuss the Dolphin's Madden Ratings

[Fins917]

I think they've underrated quite a few.

To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

[Fins917]

here's my main issue. misi.

all of these guys are olb/de drafted AFTER him. and ricky sapp at the end is a freaking 5th rounder and better!


Misi 67 ovr, 82 spd, 66 str, 88 acc

Kindle 78 ovr, 82 spd, 69 str, 95 acc

Dunlap 74 ovr, 84 spd, 77 str, 88 acc

Lee 70 ovr, 83 spd, 71 str, 72 acc

Butler 72 ovr, 84 spd, 74 str, 93 acc

Bowman 73 ovr, 82 spd, 69 str, 92 acc

Sapp 68 ovr, 85 spd, 67 str, 94 acc

[Tunaphish429]

here's my main issue. misi.

all of these guys are olb/de drafted AFTER him. and ricky sapp at the end is a freaking 5th rounder and better!


Misi 67 ovr, 82 spd, 66 str, 88 acc

Kindle 78 ovr, 82 spd, 69 str, 95 acc

Dunlap 74 ovr, 84 spd, 77 str, 88 acc

Lee 70 ovr, 83 spd, 71 str, 72 acc

Butler 72 ovr, 84 spd, 74 str, 93 acc

Bowman 73 ovr, 82 spd, 69 str, 92 acc

Sapp 68 ovr, 85 spd, 67 str, 94 acc

If a player is considered to be a reach the Madden Ratings seem to always reflect that...

Kindle was suppose to be a first round pick and slide down because of an injury...

The Ricky Sapp rating baffles the mind..but Misi didnt have alot of production in college and I bet his NCAA rating was low..

If he plays well he will go up

[KTOWNFINFAN]

One thing I found interesting is Sean Smith has a higher catching rating than ANY of our TEs (tied with Fasino) and only 6 less than Hartline. This from a guy that didn't intercept a single ball last year.
They also have Chris Clemons acceleration as 95?? Wow,ok, whatever. Don't know where that came from.

Also how is it that Gaychez is an 82 with 83 accuracy while Henne, who was better than Gaychez in every meaningful catagory is a 79 with 78 accuracy? Gaychez threw more inerceptions, and had a lower completion % yet has a higher accuracy ratings. BS!!!!

[Tunaphish429]

One thing I found interesting is Sean Smith has a higher catching rating than ANY of our TEs (tied with Fasino) and only 6 less than Hartline. This from a guy that didn't intercept a single ball last year.
They also have Chris Clemons acceleration as 95?? Wow,ok, whatever. Don't know where that came from.

He was a converted WR before he was moved to CB at Utah..

So sometimes madden is accurate

Clemons ran in the high 4.4's before we drafted him

[Fins917]

i know he was considered a reach, but you gotta take into account draft position. and the fact that he's going to be penciled in as a starter from day 1 for a decent dolphins team this year.