Who would you rather have on this years team? Welker & Chambers? or Satele & Henne

[jlfin]

Originally Posted by DownDolfin

If we had the " right " people running this team.We'd talking about how great it is to have all 4 guys.

we had NO chance of retaining Welker. Do you seriously believe that he was worth a 1st rd tender?
They put a 2nd rd tender on him, which I thought was very generous.
In addition, welker had no desire to stay on this team.
He is replaceable. Nice slot receiver, with good hands, but with no big play ability. Undersized and afraid to take a hit. He catches the ball and falls down rather than taking a hit.

[DownDolfin]

Originally Posted by jlfin

we had NO chance of retaining Welker. Do you seriously believe that he was worth a 1st rd tender?
They put a 2nd rd tender on him, which I thought was very generous.
In addition, welker had no desire to stay on this team.
He is replaceable. Nice slot receiver, with good hands, but with no big play ability. Undersized and afraid to take a hit. He catches the ball and falls down rather than taking a hit.

If Bill was running things then Welker would still be here.

How did any of this come to "" is Welker worth a a 1st rd tender ""

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwX_y5ACy-Y

[shula_guy]

Can I pick all 4? Seriously we could of kept who we had and still got them

[Chi-Town FinFan]

Originally Posted by shula_guy

Can I pick all 4? Seriously we could of kept who we had and still got them

I guess you're saying by drafting Quinn instead of Ginn and then drafting Satele in Beck's spot and picking Henne over Merling with the #32 this year?

[dlockz]

Originally Posted by Ted

D he had 4 touchdowns on the year and in 3 playoff games he did have 16 catches but only 1 TD. He also costs the Chargers 5.1 mil this season and 4.5 next. It will be interesting to see if his numbers decline this season the way they declined with us.

It would be interesting to see what he could have done with an NFL starting qb here .Catches are catches, he has always been a good td producer.

[dlockz]

Originally Posted by dreamwalker

See thats why i like this board so much, we can disagree hard on somethings and agree on others. People were too hard on chambers, his is as good or better than everyone we have right now BUT...his ceiling is not even close to what Ginn's ceiling is. If he develops and continues his progression he could be Moss, Owens great- Chambers could NEVER be that good.

At this point yea Ginn has a higher ceiling but I firmly believe with the right team Chambers would have been a great player. He does have concentration issues but so does Owens. He has a great combo of speed, size and jumping ability. There are basically less than 5 receivers that can jump in the same area code as him. I see Ginn as a good receiver, never great but we in my opinion wasted Chambers talent by barely even providing backup like talent at Wr. Chambers basically had similar talent at Qb to what Moss had in his mediocre years in oakland.

I would take Chambers over Ginn right now for the same money.