Rank These 5 Qbs

LoneWulF · 02-19-2006, 09:10 AM

I am aware we dont make the decision, and that these thread have been around for a while and are getting old, btu please rank these 5, stay open minded, and describe for each why you would or wouldnt want them
Daunte Culpepper
Drew Brees
Chad Pennington
Steve Mcnair
Aaron Brooks
i think these are the 5 most likely guys we will see

Id take them in the exact order listed above. Ill describe why later, but my battery is about to die. Remember, no ones opinion is bad, maybe we can all come to some agreement on what kind of qb wed like to have next year. Also , does anyone think Saban plans to just draft Cutler and keep Frerotte at starter?

CashInFist · 02-19-2006, 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoneWulF

I am aware we dont make the decision, and that these thread have been around for a while and are getting old, btu please rank these 5, stay open minded, and describe for each why you would or wouldnt want them
Daunte Culpepper
Drew Brees
Chad Pennington
Steve Mcnair
Aaron Brooks
i think these are the 5 most likely guys we will see

Id take them in the exact order listed above. Ill describe why later, but my battery is about to die. Remember, no ones opinion is bad, maybe we can all come to some agreement on what kind of qb wed like to have next year. Also , does anyone think Saban plans to just draft Cutler and keep Frerotte at starter?

1. Duante
2. Brees
3. McNair
4. Brooks
5. Pennington

Der Philth · 02-19-2006, 09:18 AM

Brees
CPepp
McNair
Chad (depending on his recovery)
Brooks

burger13 · 02-19-2006, 09:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CashInFist

1. Duante
2. Brees
3. McNair
4. Brooks
5. Pennington

:yeahthat:

csabe · 02-19-2006, 09:22 AM

1. Duante--knee problem persist into next year but clearly the most talented of the group
2. Brees--shoulder issues to an already not very strong arm but a smart player.
3. McNair--Old and injuries have made him miss many, many games the last 2 seasons.
4. Brooks--This guy has all the skills but makes some of the most boneheaded plays ever.
5. Pennington--Too much of an overall risk with 2 surgeries on that bum shoulder. His arm is toast.

GRYPHONK · 02-19-2006, 09:25 AM

Right now, taking injuries into effect.

1) Brees
2)Mcnair
3) Daunte(only because no one knows how long it will be till he plays)
4)Brooks
5) Pennington

SCall13 · 02-19-2006, 09:27 AM

Brees
Culpepper
McNair
Brooks
and in the distance....Pennington

SoDakDolfan · 02-19-2006, 09:31 AM

1. Daunte- Incredible physical abilities. For a QB a knee injury is easier to come back from than a shoulder injury (hence Breese below this spot). He is familiar with our basic system. And he has a good number of years left. If the fumbling problem (more fumbles than TD passes) can be corrected with coaching Daunte would be an outstanding pick up.
2. Brees- Shoulder injury really scares me but I was a fan of his before he was drafted. Still upset we let him slide past us. He is smart and can make the throws.
3. Brooks- Awesome skills, mediocre brain. If he could be taught to think he might actually be the best, but that is a big if.
4. McNair- Too old and way too injury prone. He couldn't even practice with his team last year. How would he learn a new system and develop a rythm with all new players?
4 1/2. Josh McCown- You didn't list him as an option but I had to put him in. He is young and still learning, although unproven. I wouldn't mind seeing what he could do with some good coaching. I might actually take him before McNair.
5. Pennington- Only if we absolutely had no other choice. Good skills but injuries may (probably will) ruin career.

FrankieG · 02-19-2006, 09:38 AM

Brees - A probowl QB that many want to write off because of one injury

Pennington - When he's healthy the jets are good, when he isnt they are bad. We have a solid backup in Gus if he goes down, but even if he does, I would bet that he could win against a few teams that Gus couldn't.

Culpepper - The vikings looked pretty horrible until he got injured, and then they started winning.

Mcnair - After seeing the probowl, at least our QB now can get the ball in his hands before turning it over.

Brooks - Too many bonehead plays.

Ruderic · 02-19-2006, 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCall13

Brees
Culpepper
McNair
Brooks
and in the distance....Pennington

That is mine

In_Flames · 02-19-2006, 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Der Philth

Brees
CPepp
McNair
Chad (depending on his recovery)
Brooks

:yeahthat:

csabe · 02-19-2006, 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankieG

Culpepper - The vikings looked pretty horrible until he got injured, and then they started winning.

The guy does fumble too much but had a couple of really good seasons as well. Can't base everything on a Vikings team last year in major turmoil.

Perfect72 · 02-19-2006, 10:03 AM

Brees: Best Bang-for-the-Buck
Bulger: VERY accurate passer & team player. Our receivers would blossom with Bulger passing to them. Could be a relatively bargain pickup on the backside of a Rams-Vikings deal for Culpepper.
Brooks: Because he's cheap and hopefully coachable. A change of scenery can sometimes make all the difference.
McNair: Love his heart; but the rest of his body can't play up to preious levels. Could be a real "Sleeper" pickup if he doesn't want too much $$
McCown: Very Good upside. Could either have a "Brees-like" upswing in his career - or flop completely.
Culpepper: Will have some phenominal games, but lose the big ones. Not great value for $10M/Yr. Especially going to a new team that he won't be able to develop chemistry with the receivers since he won't be able to practice until who knows when.
Ramsey: Is his confidence forever shot from the Spurrier years? Again, a change of scenery could do wonders for his career.

Go Phins!

:rawk: :band2: :rockon: :blues: :happydrin :cpatch: :drinkers:

JohnDolphin73 · 02-19-2006, 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LoneWulF

I am aware we dont make the decision, and that these thread have been around for a while and are getting old, btu please rank these 5, stay open minded, and describe for each why you would or wouldnt want them
Daunte Culpepper
Drew Brees
Chad Pennington
Steve Mcnair
Aaron Brooks
i think these are the 5 most likely guys we will see

Culpepper
Brees
Brooks
McNair
Pennington (I would rather just draft a QB instead of Pennington)

CsonkYa · 02-19-2006, 10:41 AM

1.Brees-still a ? whether he can come back. May take too much to get.
2.Daunte-same as above. Id trade Ricky str8 up.
3.Brooks-Ive always liked Brooks. Needs a fresh start somewhere with the right coaches in place.
4.McNair-too injury prone for the money he wants.
5.Chad-same as above.
sidenote;If we are including Bulger, Id put him at #1. I think he'd be great with Chambers. Accurate arm and good decision/playmaker.

02-19-2006, 09:27 AM	#7
SCall13 Finheaven QB Join Date: May 2003 Location: Charlotte, NC Posts: 11,146 Thanks: 37 Thanked 46 Times in 29 Posts FH Badges Total Awards: 2	Brees Culpepper McNair Brooks and in the distance....Pennington __________________ SCall13, Jr.

02-19-2006, 10:03 AM	#13
Perfect72 It's Only Happened ONCE! Join Date: May 2004 Location: North Port, FL Posts: 120 Thanks: 4 Thanked 3 Times in 2 Posts	What About Bulger? Brees: Best Bang-for-the-Buck Bulger: VERY accurate passer & team player. Our receivers would blossom with Bulger passing to them. Could be a relatively bargain pickup on the backside of a Rams-Vikings deal for Culpepper. Brooks: Because he's cheap and hopefully coachable. A change of scenery can sometimes make all the difference. McNair: Love his heart; but the rest of his body can't play up to preious levels. Could be a real "Sleeper" pickup if he doesn't want too much $$ McCown: Very Good upside. Could either have a "Brees-like" upswing in his career - or flop completely. Culpepper: Will have some phenominal games, but lose the big ones. Not great value for $10M/Yr. Especially going to a new team that he won't be able to develop chemistry with the receivers since he won't be able to practice until who knows when. Ramsey: Is his confidence forever shot from the Spurrier years? Again, a change of scenery could do wonders for his career. Go Phins! :rawk: :band2: :rockon: :blues: :happydrin :cpatch: :drinkers:

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

02-19-2006, 09:18 AM	#3
Der Philth Starter Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Boynton Beach Posts: 154 Thanks: 9 Thanked 3 Times in 2 Posts	Brees CPepp McNair Chad (depending on his recovery) Brooks

02-19-2006, 09:22 AM	#5
csabe Pro Bowler Join Date: May 2004 Posts: 1,649 Thanks: 244 Thanked 30 Times in 23 Posts	1. Duante--knee problem persist into next year but clearly the most talented of the group 2. Brees--shoulder issues to an already not very strong arm but a smart player. 3. McNair--Old and injuries have made him miss many, many games the last 2 seasons. 4. Brooks--This guy has all the skills but makes some of the most boneheaded plays ever. 5. Pennington--Too much of an overall risk with 2 surgeries on that bum shoulder. His arm is toast.

02-19-2006, 09:25 AM	#6
GRYPHONK Pro Bowler Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 1,663 Thanks: 78 Thanked 109 Times in 73 Posts	Right now, taking injuries into effect. 1) Brees 2)Mcnair 3) Daunte(only because no one knows how long it will be till he plays) 4)Brooks 5) Pennington

02-19-2006, 09:31 AM	#8
SoDakDolfan Land Locked Dolfan Join Date: Aug 2005 Location: South Dakota Age: 46 Posts: 1,179 Thanks: 6 Thanked 6 Times in 6 Posts	1. Daunte- Incredible physical abilities. For a QB a knee injury is easier to come back from than a shoulder injury (hence Breese below this spot). He is familiar with our basic system. And he has a good number of years left. If the fumbling problem (more fumbles than TD passes) can be corrected with coaching Daunte would be an outstanding pick up. 2. Brees- Shoulder injury really scares me but I was a fan of his before he was drafted. Still upset we let him slide past us. He is smart and can make the throws. 3. Brooks- Awesome skills, mediocre brain. If he could be taught to think he might actually be the best, but that is a big if. 4. McNair- Too old and way too injury prone. He couldn't even practice with his team last year. How would he learn a new system and develop a rythm with all new players? 4 1/2. Josh McCown- You didn't list him as an option but I had to put him in. He is young and still learning, although unproven. I wouldn't mind seeing what he could do with some good coaching. I might actually take him before McNair. 5. Pennington- Only if we absolutely had no other choice. Good skills but injuries may (probably will) ruin career.

02-19-2006, 09:38 AM	#9
FrankieG Scout Team Join Date: Aug 2004 Posts: 115 Thanks: 1 Thanked 15 Times in 9 Posts	Brees - A probowl QB that many want to write off because of one injury Pennington - When he's healthy the jets are good, when he isnt they are bad. We have a solid backup in Gus if he goes down, but even if he does, I would bet that he could win against a few teams that Gus couldn't. Culpepper - The vikings looked pretty horrible until he got injured, and then they started winning. Mcnair - After seeing the probowl, at least our QB now can get the ball in his hands before turning it over. Brooks - Too many bonehead plays.

02-19-2006, 10:41 AM	#15
CsonkYa All-Madden Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Toronto Posts: 33 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	1.Brees-still a ? whether he can come back. May take too much to get. 2.Daunte-same as above. Id trade Ricky str8 up. 3.Brooks-Ive always liked Brooks. Needs a fresh start somewhere with the right coaches in place. 4.McNair-too injury prone for the money he wants. 5.Chad-same as above. sidenote;If we are including Bulger, Id put him at #1. I think he'd be great with Chambers. Accurate arm and good decision/playmaker.

Rank These 5 Qbs

What About Bulger?