Is RG111 that much better then Joe Webb?

[CallMeDaddy]

Name another successful QB currently in the league under 6'2". I'll give you Vick as a starter. Name another one.

Robert Griffin is 6'2" so why should I name ones under?

6'2":Tony Romo, Andy Dalton, Aaron Rodgers, and Kurt Warner(not in the league anymore obviously, but still not bad numbers)

But that's besides the point, the point was people who judge people by height only want to look at his height and completely ignore his talent. Drew Brees and Michael Vick were perfect examples of why you shouldn't judge people by their height.

[Romy148]

Wow this topic is a waste of Time if Joe webb was a good as Griffin he would had won Heisman in college.!!

[Valandui]

Robert Griffin is 6'2" so why should I name ones under?

6'2":Tony Romo, Andy Dalton, Aaron Rodgers, and Kurt Warner(not in the league anymore obviously, but still not bad numbers)

But that's besides the point, the point was people who judge people by height only want to look at his height and completely ignore his talent. Drew Brees and Michael Vick were perfect examples of why you shouldn't judge people by their height.

When I said he might be, I meant that I seriously doubt it. In fact, I'd be surprised if he's even 6'. I sure as Hell don't think he's 220 lbs.

[Valandui]

Wow this topic is a waste of Time if Joe webb was a good as Griffin he would had won Heisman in college.!!

Tim Tebow won a Heisman. Tom Brady didn't. Who would you rather have at QB?

[CallMeDaddy]

When I said he might be, I meant that I seriously doubt it. In fact, I'd be surprised if he's even 6'. I sure as Hell don't think he's 220 lbs.

I still don't see why it matters how tall he is? If he's a successful Quarterback in the league It's not because his height(or lack thereof) and if he's unsuccessful it won't be because of his height(definitely not a major factor)

[CallMeDaddy]

Tim Tebow won a Heisman. Tom Brady didn't. Who would you rather have at QB?

Bill Belichick could make could make Tebow an all-star.
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

[Romy148]

Tim Tebow won a Heisman. Tom Brady didn't. Who would you rather have at QB?

thats not the point man the point is, how can u compare a guy who won Heisman and seems like a top of the line QB when it comes to talent and ability to a guy like Joe Webb is the back up to the back up in Minnesota???

[KingDolphin57]

To the Op , obviously you haven't watched alot of Baylor Football games. I won't pile on though. I'll just say no Webb is not better or equal to RG3.

[JCane]

Robert Griffin is 6'2" so why should I name ones under?

6'2":Tony Romo, Andy Dalton, Aaron Rodgers, and Kurt Warner(not in the league anymore obviously, but still not bad numbers)

But that's besides the point, the point was people who judge people by height only want to look at his height and completely ignore his talent. Drew Brees and Michael Vick were perfect examples of why you shouldn't judge people by their height.

Off-topic for a minute....

Mike Vick sucks as a QB. Pure dog ****. No pun intended.

[jlfin]

QB success is based on accuracy/ball placement and decision making/anticipation. Mobility is a plus, but not necessary. Arm strength is over valued (the so called rocket armed QB)
Those that make quick decisions and place the ball where it needs to go are the ones who have success .
Those who don't, become career backups.
Comparing one QB's physical attributes and playing style mean nothing if you don't take into account what's between the ears.
Ryan Leaf reminded me of Marino coming out of college. Brash, confident and with a strong arm. The similarities ended there.
Jay Fiedler physically reminded me of Joe Montana (mobility, size, arm strength), But the similarities ended there.