Don't blame Tanny

[PATSSUCK]

Then please explain why Brandon Weeden who has about the same talent as Tannehill around him and a new offense he is still learning is out playing Tannehill. I think Tannehill is a loser and so far his track record bears it out.

By outplaying him do you mean 12 picks and a 67 QBR. Clueless bull**** as usual

[phinking]

By outplaying him do you mean 12 picks and a 67 QBR. Clueless bull**** as usual

Weeden IS outplaying Tannehill. Yes he has 1 more Int than Tannehill but he also has 5 more TD passes. So evidentley I have much more of a clue than you do.

[TheWarriorFins]

Then please explain why Brandon Weeden who has about the same talent as Tannehill around him and a new offense he is still learning is out playing Tannehill. I think Tannehill is a loser and so far his track record bears it out.

You don't think a 29 year old should be more NFL ready than tannehill ?

[finjim]

Yep, while I agree that Tannehill doesn't have much to work with neither did Henne. I remember these exact same threads popping up. I'm not comparing Henne and Tanne talent wise, just saying that the majority of posters on this site desperately want a franchise QB so they crown them WAY too early. I'm willing to be patient with Tannehill for a total of three seasons, only then can he reasonably be judged one way or the other.

Ummmm....Henne had Brandon Marshall. Tannehill doesn't.

Class dismissed.

[Elle Clouds]

I just don't want fin fans to start sounding like Jet fans when defending Sanchez. Let Tannehill earn the label franchise qb. At this point, he has not done that and should be still "under evaluation" because he is just that. No more, no less.

[PATSSUCK]

Weeden IS outplaying Tannehill. Yes he has 1 more Int than Tannehill but he also has 5 more TD passes. So evidentley I have much more of a clue than you do.

Doubt it considering you though Moore moved the offense so much better in the Jets games when he didn't.

[Elle Clouds]

I'm just not sold on Tannehill yet. He is a rookie, but I won't be buying a jersey until he can prove that he will be here for years to come while playing at a high level ala Luck or Griffin.

[PATSSUCK]

I'm just not sold on Tannehill yet. He is a rookie, but I won't be buying a jersey until he can prove that he will be here for years to come while playing at a high level ala Luck or Griffin.

Agreed

[finjim]

I'm just not sold on Tannehill yet. He is a rookie, but I won't be buying a jersey until he can prove that he will be here for years to come while playing at a high level ala Luck or Griffin.

Too early to say Luck or RGIII are going to amount to anything. Give it another year and get back to me.

[jtoomuch]

I just don't want fin fans to start sounding like Jet fans when defending Sanchez. Let Tannehill earn the label franchise qb. At this point, he has not done that and should be still "under evaluation" because he is just that. No more, no less.

I always felt that Ireland didn't really want to draft RT but was forced to do so by public opinion. I was not thrilled with the pick at the time but I was pleasantly surprised when RT played well. Now of course, he has not looked as good. Time will tell, and I hope he turns out to be a good one, but he has only really looked good in a few games, and poor in a few games. My opinion is that we may not really know until next year what we have in him.