Tannehill = Worst rookie QB of 2012?

[AphexPhin]

facepalm

[ANUFan]

No, Tannehill took over that 4th quarter against the Seahawks and led three scoring drives, including setting up the game winning field goal. That roughing the passer call was the right call and is in the NFL rule book. It is part of the game.

Help me out Nub,

What exactly do these people want? Seriously!

Do they want us to draft another Qb?
Give M.Moore the team next season?
Get another FA Qb in the offseason?

[Finfan0120]

With Brandon Marshall we would probably have seven or eight wins right now. I'm not going to bother commenting on the entirety of the poorly-thought-out first post. Just keep in mind that our starting receivers and TE's are near the worst in the league.

[kwask4]

He doesnt have any playmaking wide recievers to throw to that can consistently get seperation hopefully mathews can develop into a playmaker, hes the fastest wr we have , we also should have grabbed josh gordon if we could have

[mrhankey81701]

Help me out Nub,

What exactly do these people want? Seriously!

Do they want us to draft another Qb?
Give M.Moore the team next season?
Get another FA Qb in the offseason?

Me personally, I want to see more game by game development. He seems to have started struggling the past few weeks when teams started sitting on that 15 yd out route he and Brian Hartline had so much success with in the beginning of the season.

[ANUFan]

Me personally, I want to see more game by game development. He seems to have started struggling the past few weeks when teams started sitting on that 15 yd out route he and Brian Hartline had so much success with in the beginning of the season.

Curious what do you measure game to game development by? For example is it only TDs? which i suspect is what most "fans" measure it by! Me I see a young QB that has a much better pocket presence than he did the first game. He's moving around, avoiding pressure, subtle slides here and there and occasionally taking off. Further I see a young Qb thats starting to make throws down the middle of the field. During the last drive of the seattle game and he made his first 2 throws I knew this guy is no Henne! He was decisive and I knew he was in that rare playing zone you could feel it. Sure right now he's inconsistant but that what I expect! If we were winning nobody would care

I have seen progression and I'm excited about our future with Tannehill at the helm

[Birdmond]

Help me out Nub,

What exactly do these people want? Seriously!

Do they want us to draft another Qb?
Give M.Moore the team next season?
Get another FA Qb in the offseason?

If there were QB's of RGIII, Luck and Wilson's caliber I absolutely would want to draft another QB.
The problem is there is not. No to FA and no to Moore. I want whoever the GM is to surround Tanny Boy with so much talent there will be no excuses.

[ANUFan]

If there were QB's of RGIII, Luck and Wilson's caliber I absolutely would want to draft another QB.
The problem is there is not. No to FA and no to Moore. I want whoever the GM is to surround Tanny Boy with so much talent there will be no excuses.

Question whats more likely our record is the same with those Qb's or those respective teams records are the same with Tannehill? Personally I think Luck is the ONLY one you can somewhat make a case for...

[matt11390]

TH isn't having a good year. His TD to INT ratio is horrible. He's only thrown only what, 6 or 7 TD's? Hoping him playing his rookie year will allow hi to mature to a better one in the future.

[Nublar7]

Help me out Nub,

What exactly do these people want? Seriously!

Do they want us to draft another Qb?
Give M.Moore the team next season?
Get another FA Qb in the offseason?

Tannehill was the 3rd quarterback taken in a draft compared to that of the 1983 quarterback class. If Tannehill was in the 2013 quarterback class, I think it is very likely he would be the first quarterback off the board. Could even go #1.