Tannehill = Worst rookie QB of 2012?

[dolpns13]

Look, lets be realistic, Tannehill isnt performing as well as the other rookies aside from Weeden. Yes he has no weapons but he still does make his fair share of mistakes. Rookie mistakes. I still see so much more upside in this kid and I fully expect him to have a much improved season next year.

[hooshoops]

i'll tell ya one thing i do see though...both rg3 and russell wilsons o coordinators are REALLY helping their qbs succeed with the way they call the game and the play design etc...i'm not so sure i see much evidence of that with mike sherman...haven't seen the first rub route or clear out and run a guy underneath in the red zone all season haven't seen any intuitive looking bubble screens not much motion with the wrs...took til this week to come out of 2 wr base i form sets on early downs and get into more spread type stuff

i see a lot of old fashioned play calling and design...

[hrpuffin]

I keep hearing we need weapons. How does a weapon make the QB throw the ball to wide open receivers?

[Dick Pepperwood]

Dude I Don't Think Tannehill is the Worst. I think up to now he has been Ok/Average. Which is Fine for a Rookie. I think the Problem is, RG3 and Luck are Outright Studs right now and making Both those Teams Playoff Contenders. You can say we Lack Playmakers and all that, but the Colts were 2-14 Last Year. RG3 Beat the Giants yesterday they are truly Super Rookies. Tannehill right now is not in that Class. The other Factor is Russell Wilson in Seattle. Those Look 3 Teams headed in the Right Direction because of QB Play. Our Guy Cant Outright carry our Team. Kaepernick and SF Too. It is a Tough Year to be a Rookie QB named Tannehill, he is not in the Conversation with those Dudes. Plain and Simple.

[dolpns13]

Its pretty funny actually.. You guys act like he misses wide open receivers every single time he throws to one. Yeah, he missed them so get over it. Pretty funny you are arguing that we still do not need upgrades at WR, that you think we are set at the position.

I keep hearing we need weapons. How does a weapon make the QB throw the ball to wide open receivers?

[Harry_Bagpipe]

Its pretty funny actually.. You guys act like he misses wide open receivers every single time he throws to one. Yeah, he missed them so get over it. Pretty funny you are arguing that we still do not need upgrades at WR, that you think we are set at the position.

Seriously. Ive seen the kid throw some damn perfect passes with the velocity and in windows only a handful of qbs today could make

[DANTODUPER]

Is there one worse? I'm not projecting the future, just the present. It seems like even Weeden is a better player.

RT did beat Seattle, then Wilson crushed the Bears on the road while RT stunk it up again.
There were later-round picks who sit, but RT is the worst starting rookie QB.
That kinda sucks.

Damn, I hate being so snakebit. Tannehill is Exactly who he was predicted to be.
Luck and RG3 are QBs of a generation and Tannehill is like David Woodley or, gulp, a young Alex Smith.
Things just never work out for us. I mean, Matt Moore could already be better than Tannehill will ever be.

At best, Tannehill will be an 'if' for another whole season. Johnny Football will probably be better, get drafted by the Jets, and kick our ass next year. Eagles QB Nick Foles might be better. Can U point to any QB and say with certainty "Tannehill is better than that guy"?

I root for Miami but I only have loyalty to winning players. Tannehill is a multimillionaire, **** him if he doesn't play well. Earn your money!

Frustrated fan. I'm trolling cuz I'm pissed and still pissed about that Buffalo game.

This can come true, however it is too soon to make a prediction. But based on what I have seen it looks like Luck and RGIII are studs, Weeden and Wilson could be franchise QB's and Tannehill and Foles need some improvement. What worries me is Tannehill is the only one playing on a familiar scheme and still very few touchdowns. What gives me hope is that he was the less NFL ready of all 5 top QB's, so I hope there is a huge upside.

[danstilldaman]

This thread=worst thread of 2012

[Birdmond]

The more I see RG3, Luck, Wilson, and even Weeden throwing TDs to play makers and making plays makes me despise Ireland more and more. It really isn't fair.

Yeah, that's why at my house Ryan Tannehill is referred to as "The Consolation Prize".

[Phindog]

I'm with you and you are one of the few on this board who is wise enough to see that the Colts gamed the league and got away with it. There are many who post on here who are apathetic about it like it didnt affect them when in fact every highlight shown of Luck on espn could & probably should have been for the very team they are crying about today.

As far as the guy we got...He is a project and a risky one at that. He has more experience catching the ball than throwing it and up to right now has not proven he is a legit NFL qb. If he pans out great but if not I hear Hartline throws a tight spiral...

"You cannot fix stupid" Ron White

Ron White may have been directing that at you?

Tannyhill is a legit NFL QB.......He's starting silly...