Last edited by MDFINFAN; 06-07-2010 at 04:46 PM. Reason: 2 threads on same subject
I do not agree that she should be fired unless she is effecting the sales or ratings for whichever media outlet that pays her. If that is occuring then an argument on that basis could be made. The lady is entitled to her opinion no matter how offensive it is or to how many. I defend her right as I do anyone elses. I do agree with the article that there is a double standard and she is getting a pass that she would not be getting if she was talking about other select races. I do not approve of that but not because she does not have the right to speak her mind but because everyone has the right to speak thier mind regardless of who it offends. Her comments do not make her a better or worse journalist then she has always been. I never considered her objective and this has done nothing to alter my opinion of her. I will tell you the truth I do not really believe what she said by itself quailifies as proof that she is in fact anti-semtic. She only said she believed the land belongs to the Palenstines and the land they occuppy historically was won by the Isreals in a war. This is not much different then how the rest of the world formed its borders but it certainily is a matter of opinion who is entitled to that land. Sucks for the Palestines because they lost and Isreal has our support. Isreal has a big brother.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/37555003/ns/politics/Thomas has apologized for the comments, which were captured on video by an interviewer for the website “RabbiLIVE.com.”
On the May 27 video, Thomas says Israelis should "get the hell out of Palestine," suggesting they go to Germany, Poland or the U.S.
Those remarks drew sharp criticism from the Obama administration earlier Monday, as well as the cancellation of a high school graduation speech she was to deliver.
She deserved it. You can't say those kind of things when you're in the position she is. Long story short, Helen Thomas sucks.
i dont agree with her. but i dont agree that you should just fire people based on their extreme opinions.
Fired? No. Should she retire? at 89....she is more than due.
Players come and go, but I will always be a Miami Dolphins Fan first and foremost.
I would fire her if it was my paper
"As scarce as truth is, the supply has always been in excess of the demand."
Henry Wheeler Shaw