But you don't take a center in the first rd unless he is the next Dwight Stevenson.
Hell,Pouncy isn't even a Nick Mangold.
I would have traded down to the bottom of the first and taken Mark Ingram....and please don't
compare Thomas to Mark,then with the 2nd that our GM should have got,if he was competent,
grab a guard then.
Now,not having to trade away our 3rd,we could taken a chance on Mallett or another player.
See,what chaps me off about our front office....is the draft was dictated by us not having a 2nd round
pick because Jeff overpaid for Marshall....never should have given two 2's for him..a 2nd and a 4th should have done it.
Denver would not have got that deal from anyone else...Jeff panicked.
I've got a bad feeling they are going to do something stupid with some of our picks next year...causing the same
problem in next years draft.
It's just a silly incompetent cycle with these buffoons.
It's Wanny all over again.
I think some of these players will be good,I just don't see greatness.
I've watched all most all of Pouncy's games...He isn't his brother.
My Tide manhandled him...He isn't that strong or elite.
Just the way i feel...been a Dolphin fan since 1970....this is getting old.
Oh yeah...Matt Forte is a average NFL back...I expect better.
Last edited by Namor; 04-30-2011 at 10:14 PM.
I'm positive & gave it a B, 15% rated it an A?? ... GROINK!!! Yet, on paper means nothing, BUT ...
Everyone is all crazy over the "Trees", but let's look at the "Forest" ....
Ireland has wrestled near absolute power & made some BOLD moves (yes, it takes balls to pick interior lineman #15 & then make a lot of trades for "YOUR GUY") ...
So, NOW we can JUDGE Ireland ... & he's the future of the Franchise much more than a QB or any other person (Tony was emasculated by Harbuagh-gate) ... Ireland also has Free Agency so his job is only 1/2 done this year ...
If Ireland chooses STUDs ... its just a matter of time before we're good, as he is picking needs.
If Ireland chooses DUDs ... freakanomics deja vu of the last decade.
Can't wait to find out ... we'll have a good idea in the last half of next season.
Too all you Mallett babies, I will point you to the OSU game to see how he handles pressure up the middle. Pouncy is a top tier talent and graded very high, so he wasn't a reach.
D Thomas with a solid oline will be a nice fresh start from Ronnie IMO.
People really need to get over not drafting Ryan Leaf v2.0. The guy will be buried away through his rookie contract. Next year franchise QBs will be in abundance IMO. And with this talent should we need one, will make his transition easier.
Either way this season will be judgement day for the FO and Henne. And I do believe this team got better.
I think a solid B as well.If you dont think theirs a top notch QB to have a future with,then why draft one and waste the pick. Henne has shown potential at times,what he has to do is do it consistently ! So,put players around him and give him the possible chance to suceed, and maybe address a QB to back him up,compete with him in FA.
I feel B is fair, and those who are giving it a C is also fair. I just can't help but feel people are more concerned about who we DIDN'T draft rather than who we did.
Look, drafting Pouncey was lackluster, but it filled a need. He is a very good player and should be a very good player for us in the long run. I've said all a long I was not a huge fan. I felt better after seeing the rest of the first round (which was a meat and potatoes 1st round), and again, Pouncey should be an above average starter for us for the awhile..
Daniel Thomas isn't fast, but I feel people are looking too much at his workout numbers and not his play on the field. It was a solid pick, but again I feel people are more worried about us not taking Mallett. Thomas will contribute and fits with Daboll's philosophy.
Edmond Gates is a speed demon (who I have known about for months for the poster who said nobody knew about him before last night) who gives us that vertical threat we lack. Sure he is raw as a route runner, but when you have Bess, Marshall, and Hartline he doesn't need to be great at it. He just needs to catch and use his speed.
Charles Clay is an interesting pick. I didn't know much about him, but he is a name I kept in the back of my head thanks to CK and TedSlimm. He is a vertical threat at TE/FB/H-Back, and can be used to create several mismatches. Very Raw as a player, but with Fasano (and even Polite) he doesn't need to be a great blocker, just a threat in the open field.
Kearse I'm not committed either way. Nice project player that COULD develop into a backup NT, and in a 34 defense you can never have enough NTs in your camp.
The Montana pick I can't get behind cause of the depth we have at CB.
We filled needs at C, RB, WR, TE, and backup NT with guys with potential so I can't call it a failure. Aside from Pouncey and the 2 7th rounders everybody was begging for offensive playmakers and we got 3 potential playmakers for the offense. We just have to be patient.
I'm a Jets fan, but I don't get why some of you guys are upset. You need a QB, but there wasn't one worth drafting at your position. Would you have rather done what the Titans and Vikings did? Pouncey and Thomas will be very good players and you'll soon be telling me how they're better than Mangold and Greene.