Do the Giants have an elite defense?
That's a fair question to ask, right?
SF D's allowed 14 PPG(opposing O's averaged 27 PPG in reg seasons) +13
Eli led offenses to 18 PPG in SBs(opposing D's allowed avg of 19 PPG) -1
NYG D's allowed 16 PPG(opposing O's averaged 34 PPG) + 18
which was better?
---------- Post added at 10:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:45 AM ----------
Furthermore, rail on him for the regular season all you want but he's never led the Giants to a losing season since taking over a full season as starter. You don't know what you're arguing.
But you're also the guy who campaigned hard for Chad Pennington, Herm Edwards, and then Eric Mangini--so your football opinions are questionable on their best days
Chad was a very good QB, herm a good HC for us and I don't remember going nuts for Mangini but none of that has anything to do w/ this topic. Nice deflection.
Never a losing season? has mark buttfumble ever led his team to a losing season? not even as a rookie where eli was 1-6 as a rookie
NFC East is weak?
stop trying to deflect from your weak argument