Did you see the ESPN article of Tim Tebow running shirtless in the rain?
buttfumble can succeed with more weapons; he's shown a killer instinct in games that matter. You don't make conference championships without skill. Yeah he's uneven but like Junc said numbers are only part of the story. Being a Fin fan I'd much rather face Tebow than buttfumble as a starting QB.
However when your career numbers are equal to Chad Henne you've going to get criticized.
I agree with Junc; Tebow is a Wildcat QB designed to take advantage of mismatches on defense. You have to accout for him as a runner and a thrower. He may not be deadly like Cam Newton or even Mike Vick but he creates mismatches.
-Sharkbait, woo hah haa
"I guess I'm gonna have to say it. I'm not going to be the head coach of Alabama." -The Nicktator
"The Ginn family is going to be a great addition to this football team." -Cam Cam Cam
If you are talking about wins, Bills haven't had a winning season since...since...since I don't know 15 years? Where as MS has probably won more games as a starter in last three years than the Bills have in the last decade.
If you were a Patriots fan, I wouldn't even argue. They've been an elite team for a long long time with a lot to show for. Being a Bills fan, you don't merit such questioning.