W/ one argument we were arguing if Eli is elite, one of my arguments against him was he hasn't had the reg season consistency to be elite as we saw in 2 SB years where they won 9 and 10 games. he had SB talent and could only win 9 and 10 games, in the 9 win year of 2011 he played in a very weak division and could only lead them to 9 wins. Combine that w/ missing 3 of the last 4 postseasons and it isn't elite worthy. What does that have to do w/ Mark buttfumble? at what point was I saying mark is elite? you are smart enough not to confuse 2 totally different arguments.
How many regular season wins each season does it take for you to consider a QB elite? Why do they matter for elite QBs but not other QBs. For a guy who places so much value on a QBs worth from two divisional round wins, I would think you would put a lot more value on 2 Super Bowls wins.
In the last 5 years, who do you think the Elite Qbs are?