Last 5 years:
Last 5 years:
I have a hard time putting Eli on the same level as those QBs in your list, but he played a big role in getting his team to, and winning the Super Bowl. He made some really clutch passes in 2011, so I give him the elite title based on what he has done in the post season.
Since you put so much emphasis on wins instead of numbers, I would think that Eli would be at the top of your list. He's won more Super Bowls in the last 6 years than any of the other QBs that are in your list.
Wisdom from a "QB Whisperer::
"No we have our FRANCHISE QB and I want to keep him rather than get 2 guys who may or may not be productive NFL players.
Palmer's situation is different and if I had my choice between Palmer and buttfumble, I'd take buttfumble"
In the last 5 years Rodgers started for the first time in his career and went 6-10. That's a little skewed wouldn't you say?
Last 4 years:
Eli: 36 wins, 1 playoff app
Rodgers: 46 wins, 4 playoff apps
Brees and the saints were in chaos last year w/ the suspended players and missing their HC yet still found a way to win 7 games and he's still won more games than Eli the last 5 years.
Brady missed 2008, last 5 seasons Brady has played: 65 wins, that's better than 48, right?
Clearly Eli is not an elite QB and has not won enough in reg seasons. heck, he has 2 SB rings but he's only won postseason games in those SB runs where his D has played out of this world.
You said regular season wins don't matter so what does it matter if "he didn't win enough in reg seasons"?Clearly Eli is not an elite QB and has not won enough in reg seasons. heck, he has 2 SB rings but he's only won postseason games in those SB runs where his D has played out of this world.