I'm not sure it's fair to pile on the OP for his assessment here. We didn't do a good job of chewing up the clock at the end of the game, and the Clay play wasn't the only pass play we had that probably should have been a run. That said we won, and I have faith in Phibin. ALL coaches make decisions that will get second guessed a lot. Goes with the territory. The guy on the other side of the field is likely to make some mistakes too, and if you have a good coach (and I think Philbin is) at the very least the game management errors will balance out. I thought it was dumb to take the penalty on Cincis holding call on there last drive. 2nd and 20 or 3rd and 10 with very limited time on the clock. IMHO the lost down was greater value than ten yds when they have to go the field, but it is what it is. Hard not to be positive though about the sum of Philbins work to this point.