Yes! 2 of those 3 years playing for the Conference Championship = "Elite"
Yes (somewhat): Elite in '09 and '10 but surely not in '11
No! No Superbowl, not even a division championship.
No! One legit year in '10 sandwiched between Colts giftwrapping and mediocrity
Junc, you used to be pretty reasonable, but you've jumped the shark with the buttfumble and Jets stuff lately.