Sonny, you've been bought and sold by CK and Hooshoops, 2 of FH's best talent "scouts" both of whom could teach you a lot if you could only put your ego aside, among others pointing out the obvious flaws in your analysis. But consider yourself lucky that Slimm Jr who's also forgotten more than you know and is not always the most PC, didn't weigh in to pummel you also.
Instead of defending an indefensible position, at your age, and obviously still steep learning curve, you should turn this humbling experience into a valuable lifetime learning experience if you're serious about becoming a real scout:
Any opinion is subjective; however there's a consensus that can't be overlooked. And instead of entrenching yourself defending a shaky position, capitulate to more realistic input, especially when it's multiplied by folks who obviously know at least as much or more than you, turning it into a learning experience as input you should consider in the future before going out on a limb.
When developing your opinions, you need to re-think your methodologies used, including sample size universe, extenuating circumstances beyond measurable paradigms, and solicit/weigh prior input from those whose opinions and analyses resonate at the very least as persuasively as your own.
Some have rightfullly complimented you on your knowledge and career-focus - encouraging you not to lose faith or take the age criticisms too seriously. That's basically true, however, you will find that with age comes a maturity to subjugate your own ego, pride of authorship and overall hubris to the collective wisdom of others, concede your wrong, move on and (most importantly) learn from the experience at the risk otherwise of appearing immature and truculent.
I can go on and on, but hopefully you will look back in the future at this back-of-the-barn spanking as a seminal learning moment you'll come to appreciate the older you get.
"I worry about wins; I don't worry about meaningless fantasy #s"
(fine for RT17 but not when it comes to someone's HC and beloved QB)