I know it's a little different because I'm giving a college football example, but going into the 2007 draft Calvin Johnson at Georgia Tech had almost the exact numbers as Dwayne Jarrett at USC, but to most people it was clear that Johnson was a much better player. To give a recent NFL example Hakeem Nicks had 100 targets, 53 receptions for 692 yards and three touchdowns last year, while Brandon Gibson had 82 targets, 51 receptions for 691 yards and 5 touchdowns. Most people will tell you that Nicks without doubt is the better player despite having similar numbers.