I would immediately eliminate Mark Ingram from that list until he has proven some consistency. I wouldn't start Gibson personally because of my homerism (I would think that's the only reason I'm starting him). Golden Tate could have a good game since I'm not sure how much they will go to Rice with his knee. Personally, I would select Tavon because they say that he will be used in packages that weren't shown in preseason and that could be exciting. Good Luck.