According to ESPN's total QBR stat, they are both pretty close so far. Not that I love this stat.
Tannehill is in year 2, he should be better right now. Geno is a rookie learning a new system and the speed of the NFL. Hes made some dumb rookie mistakes, but hes also made a lot of "wow" plays that shows his talent. I think Geno is going to be better than buttfumble, but will he be a franchise QB? Still early in the season, who knows how good Geno will be or Tannehill. But lets not act like Tannehill has been a star so far.
But how about their first 5 games?
169 attempts 97 completions. 57%
2 TD 5 INT
1 rushing TD
156 attempts 94 completions. 60%
7 TD 8 INT
1 rushing TD
He never proved himself to be anything more then a below average QB who was capable of elevating his level of play from time to time.
Idk what Geno is going to end up being, but so far i'm fairly happy with what i've seen and happy to put the Mark buttfumble days behind me.
"It is wonderful to be here in the great state of Chicago"
- Dan Quayle, former U.S. Vice-President
He had ONE bad year, a year w/ the worst offensive talent in the league(healthy talent) and Tony Sparano running things w/ the Tebow distraction hovering over the team.
This is why Jet fans don't deserve a winner, we finally have a guy we can win big with and they want him gone b/c he sucked in a situation no QB could succeed in.
Obviously I know Mark's career as a Jet is over(barring something incredibly crazy) but I'd take a healthy Mark on my team any day. It's not his fault since 2010 the talent eroded around him.
He went from Braylon, Holmes, Cotch and Keller in 2010 to:
-losing Braylon and getting an older WR who just spent 2 years in prison, picking up an old WR in camp and having 3 of his top 5 weapons out of football the next year.
-in 2012 he saw Chaz Schilens starting, he lost Holmes and his favorite target keller, Clyde Gates couldn't make the dolphins yet he played a prominent role for us picking him up after the season began.
Mark has proven he can win big in this league but you need talent. heck, look at Eli w/ talent Mark has never had and he's 0-5. Look at ben w/ little talent(still much more than mark had last year). Unless your name is Tom Brady you need talent to throw and handoff to in this league. When mark had it he won big, when he didn't he sucked much like Eli and ben are sucking w/ much more talent right now.