Welcome to FinHeaven Fans Forums! We're glad to have you here. Please feel free to browse the forum. We'd like to invite you to join our community; doing so will enable you to view additional forums and post with our other members.



VIP Members don't see these ads. Join VIP Now
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 23

Thread: 2005 Offseason - Position by position analysis...QB, RB, OL, WR & FB (LONG POST)

  1. -1
    Gladsadmad's Avatar
    Pro Bowler

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Mar 2003
    Posts:
    1,770
    vCash:
    1109
    Loc:
    West Palm Beach
    Thanks / No Thanks

    2005 Offseason - Position by position analysis...QB, RB, OL, WR & FB (LONG POST)

    This seems as good a time as any to look at some of the options the Dolphins will be presented with in free agency and the #2 pick in the draft. My sources for information on prospective players will be http://tsn.ca/nfl/player_list.asp, http://www.footballsfuture.com and last years Lindy's football preview (the only magazine that I'm familiar with that has comments about every player on every team's projected roster). I'll try to focus in on the most likely possibilities..(CURRENT AGE) in parenthesis.

    QUARTERBACK - It appears as though AJ Feely(27) is safe to make the team for at least one more season. As we all know, he struggled mightily but there were so many mitigating factors that could be the reason for his poor play. With top coaches like S.Linehan & Houck running the offense we could see a dramatic improvement. All reports indicate that Saban is interested in acquiring a veteran QB to help Feely along and possibly start if he falters. For that reason, I'm not going to list younger veteran QB's like M.McMahon(26) from Detroit.

    THE OPTIONS...

    Gus Frerotte(33) - Great arm...Well versed in Linehan's offense...excelled in 2003 filling in for an injured Culpepper with 6 TD's and only 1 INT in 2 starts (both wins)... Can sling the ball into tight spots. Will have hot streaks. Knows his role and has helped Culpepper develop…Seems to get worse the more he plays…Makes costly mistakes, especially when he tries to make too much happen in the red zone.

    Kelly Holcomb(31) - Has struggled since a solid 2002 season with 17 TD's and 17 INT's over the last 2 injury plagued seasons. Simply hasn't stood out when given the opportunity to be a starter. Lacks a top arm or athleticism.

    Kurt Warner(33) - Excellent accuracy. Hits his receivers in stride so they can gain yards after the catch. Has a very good arm. An excellent decision maker who quickly diagnoses and exploits coverages…Since 2002, Warner has only 10 TD’s to 16 INT’s..Has developed happy feet in the pocket and will make poor throws when not set properly. Will force some passes and give up some interceptions. His fastball has lost a little zip.

    Jeff Garcia(34) - Reads defenses very well and makes excellent decisions. Puts a nice touch on the ball and can get it deep if he has to...Career 2-to1 TD-to-INT ratio. Small, slow, and weak-armed. Fails every tape-measure test. Has a funky delivery. Has taken some hits in recent years and is getting brittle.

    Aaron Rodgers(R) - Top prospect...If drafted would likely spend a year as Feely's backup to better learn the system...He has a strong, accurate throwing arm and is capable of making all the throws…Does a great job of taking what the defense gives him underneath...Shows good mobility.

    Alex Smith(R) - Biggest strengths are his intelligence and the efficiency he plays with. He sees the field very well and makes smart decisions. He is a true junior, and he needs to bulk up to take the beating the NFL is going to give him.

    Others..Charlie Batch, Jeff Blake, Vinny Testaverde, Tony Banks

    RUNNING BACK - Very well could be the key to offensive success in 2005. Linehan employed a myriad of backs in his time as OC of the Vikings. He seemed to use the pass the set up the run (very different than what we are used to around here). If Saban gives him autonomy as has been reported, Linehan could be allowed to mold the offense as he sees fit. Mewelde Moore, Ontarrio Smith & Michael Bennett all fit the same mold, so I wouldn't be surprised to see the Dolphins use a smaller, speedy back. Lamar Gordon should be given a chance to start because he fits the mold..great pass catcher..speedy. More than likely Minor will be gone and S.Morris will move back to FB.

    THE OPTIONS...

    LaMont Jordan(26) - Career 4.8 yds per att in first 4 years...a short, wide runner with power who can cut on a dime. Has good vision and can find a hole. Breaks tackles and finishes runs....Can't get on the field on passing downs because he doesn't read the blitz or run tight routes.

    Ronnie Brown(R) - One of the more complete backs in this draft...has great size and very good speed. He is a physical runner that is very tough to bring down...will move the pile an extra two yards once he is hit...has the cutting ability to make the first defender miss, and the speed to get to the perimeter and break the long run...a quality receiver out of the backfield, displaying soft hands when asked to catch the ball.

    Cedric Benson(R) - Shaved off his dreads to further separate himself from comparisons to Ricky Williams...has been called a "better" version of Ricky..has very good tools across the board and looks like he is going to be a very good NFL running back...runs very hard between the tackles, and has the strength to fight for extra yards...has the ability to make people miss, and the speed to go the distance....has also displayed the ability to be a solid receiver out of the backfield. Benson is about as consistent as you can get, and he shows up to play every week.

    Cadillac Williams(R) - Does a lot of things very well...has excellent acceleration to and through the hole, and has the ability to cut and make defenders miss...runs with authority, and battles for the extra yard....possesses great vision, and just seems to know where the hole is. He is a willing inside runner, and still has the speed to be a threat on the outside... He has a slim build, and he could really use some extra pounds. It would help him be a stronger interior runner, and help him be more of a workhorse.

    Chester Taylor(25) - Excelled filling in for J.Lewis last year with 2-100 yd games in 4 starts...Runs low to the ground and makes smart, economical north-south moves...Has no breakaway speed and very average burst through the hole. Poor blocker. Wears down.

    Dominic Rhodes(26) - Limited action behind James...Darting, low center-of-gravity runner who makes quick cuts. Has a great burst and hits the hole hard. Can make people miss...A liability when pass blocking. Not a very polished receiver.

    Derrick Blaylock(25) - 8 TD's in 5 starts could be a product of the system...Ran for 186 yds & a TD vs the Saints...Decent quickness and some cutback ability. Can catch and has some open-field moves...isn't powerful or extremely fast. Doesn't always hit the hole with authority.

    Correll Buckhalter(26) - Coming off knee injury that wiped out his entire 2004 season...Has some speed and burst to the hole and will break some tackles. Decent receiver...Not a great cutback runner. Will get bottled up if the hole isn't right in front of him. Has had character issues in the past.

    Anthony (A-Train) Thomas(27) - Lost his starting job to T. Jones last year..A classic workhorse who gets it done between the tackles. Finishes every run. Reads and sets up his blocks well...Isn't a great blocker. Doesn't have the elite vision to find holes on his own. Lacks breakaway speed.

    Others...Ron Dayne, Amos Zereoue

    OFFENSIVE TACKLE – Saban himself has indicated that LT is one of the top priorities for the offseason. This leaves D.McIntosh & W.Smith somewhat in limbo. Will the fact that O-line coach H.Houck already worked with McIntosh help him or hurt him? Is Wade Smith a lost cause? This is yet to be determined. All that is certain is that Saban stated that he will not “overhaul” the line and will likely only make one significant addition. It would be logical to assume that St. Clair will at least be given an opportunity to continue to start at RT since he was fairly consistent. Another question is whether Houck & Saban will view Vernon Carey as more of a G than a T.

    THE OPTIONS…

    Jonas Jennings(27)LT - A widebody. Rock solid technique. A battler with a mean streak. Can be overpowering as a run blocker…Has trouble with speed rushers, who get the edge on him at times. Doesn't have the footwork of an outstanding left tackle…Would be a great fit with a veteran team dependant on the run looking for a young run-blocking tackle.

    Jammal Brown(R) - As a pass blocker, he shows good agility, and has long arms to keep the defender away from his chest. Physically, Brown is a very good athlete, with very good lateral agility. His long arms allow him to keep the defender off his chest…He can run block, but he doesn’t play with a great deal of power and doesn't dominates at the point. Brown plays right tackle, but his athletic skills should allow him to move over to the left side in the NFL.

    Alex Barron(R) - Tall, with very long arms, and is lanky, which shows room for growth potential. He is a very good athlete, displaying very good agility in pass protection. He slides well in either direction, and can adjust on the move. His long arms also allow him to lock on to the defender and keep them from getting under his pads…He needs a complete overhaul in his run blocking game.

    Kareem McKenzie(25)RT - Great size and wingspan. Quick feet. Moves well. Can explode out of his stance. Gets good push and can redirect his opponent…Still improving his technique. Could be more physical and intense.

    Oliver Ross(30)RT - Great wingspan. Lots of experience in the system. Latches on and can get some drive. Good footwork and some quickness…A turn-and-steer guy who doesn't blow people away. Not a polished technician. Doesn't always play with passion.

    Stockar McDougle(28)RT – Born and raised in Deerfield Bch, FL.. Massive, strong player. Can engulf and overwhelm opponents when run blocking…Doesn't have great quickness or agility. Gets heavy. When he gains weight, he's too stiff and too slow to do the job. Makes mental errors.

    Floyd Womack(26)RT - Versatile…Has worked out at every line position but center…Not a full time starter in Seattle..A huge specimen who can be a road grader when blocking straight ahead. Has learned to pass block with better technique….Will lunge and lose balance. Gets too heavy and loses foot quickness. Not a great blocker in space.

    Victor Riley(30)RT - Has shown the ability to be a dependable player whether moving the ball on the ground or through the air. He has the lower body strength to beat average defenders off the snap, and the reach to keep back pass rushers…shows an inability to adjust to the moves of a quicker rusher, and often has to overcompensate, which can cost a quarterback time.

    CENTER & GUARD – Jeno James looks to be the only interior lineman that will remain a starter, the other positions are up for competition. As we all know, Seth McKinney was below average and he must improve greatly if he is to remain the starting C. If not, he will face a challenge from a free agent, a rookie or possibly Rex Hadnot & St.Clair who both played C in college. If Hadnot doesn’t get in the mix at C, he should have a shot to win the RG position. If V.Carey is moved to guard, Hadnot will face stiff competition.

    THE OPTIONS…

    Joe Andruzzi(29)LG – Started every game for the last 2 world champion Patriot teams…Smart, hard working tough guy…a great fit for a young team looking for leadership and consistent play…He gets great angles on his blocks, and opens up wide lanes for slashing runners…He is susceptible to superior bull rushers who can beat him on brute strength.

    Marco Rivera(32)RG - A very good blocker in space…He attacks defenders off the snap, and will push the pile for an inside runner. He lacks the mobility to get out to trap or pull, so his ideal suitor will feature a power back or inside slasher. In the pass game, he locks on to his opponent effectively, and has the intelligence and recognition to anticipate the moves of his opponent and neutralize them.

    Dominic Raiola(26)C - Very quick and athletic, with adequate size. Plays hard. Has become a better technician who gets good position when pass blocking. Blocks well in space and against a moving target. Can long snap...Isn't exceptionally powerful. Still developing as a pass blocker.

    Robbie Tobeck(34)C - Strong and tenacious. A high-effort type. Makes good calls. Won't make many mistakes. A clubhouse leader...Doesn't move well. Won't be much good on a sweep or screen. Quicker tackles can slice past him.

    Bennie Anderson(28)RG - Powerful run blocker. Very good upper-body strength. Has great size and can engulf his opponent….Limited quickness and range. Not effective as a pulling guard. Quick rushers can get past him. At 335 lbs, will get fat and lose stamina.

    Casey Rabach(27)C – Started 16 games for the first time in 2004.. Smart and hard working. Has decent footwork and technique. Moves well enough to pull and trap….Isn't overpowering and doesn't always get leverage.

    Rick DeMulling(27)LG – Has been a full time starter the last 3 years for the high flying Colts offense…Good size, power and technique. Gets good position. Blocks well on the move. Can play anywhere on the interior line. Tough and dedicated….Not a great straight-ahead blocker.

    David Dixon(36)RG – Despite his age, has not missed a start the last 2 years..has played in Scott Linehan’s offense for the last 3 years.. Massive individual. A road grader as a run blocker….Struggles as a pass blocker. Quicker tackles can get around him and he has trouble picking up blitzing linebackers.

    Cosey Coleman(26)RG – Dolphins chose not to pursue him last offseason…More of a finesse player than a brute, Coleman possess the rare combination of good footwork, lower body strength, and the arm extension needed to keep defenders at bay. While he may lack the mean streak most teams look for in a lineman, Coleman would be a great fit in a precision attack that calls for many different qualities.

    Jermane Mayberry(31)LG - Gets by on brute force. He pushes the pile and gets great leverage at the point of attack simply by exerting his force. Ask him to move around in a specialized offense and he will be lost immediately. He doesnt have the athleticism required to pull and trap, and would quickly become a liability.

    Ben Hamilton(27)LG - Smart, dedicated player. Has good technique and fundamentals. A converted center who can play anywhere on the interior line. An old-school Broncos lineman who is great when pulling and trapping…Struggles to keep his weight up. Doesn't generate a lot of push when blocking in line.

    Elton Brown(R)G – He’s got great size, and plays with a lot of strength on the field. If he gets his hands on you, you’re all but done in the running game. He moves very well laterally, and is a very good overall athlete for an interior offensive lineman. He may even have the ability to slide out to RT, which will only increase his value. Brown has a ton of experience, and should be ready to play early in his NFL career.

    Ben Wilkerson(R)C - Has awesome quickness, great hands and just knows how to play the position. Is very athletic, he should become a fine pulling offensive center in the future, he has the speed and quickness to do so…He is not a giant that just dominates physically and that could be a problem in the NFL.

    Others…Roberto Garza G, Rich Tylski G, Chris Gray G, Rich Braham C

    FULLBACK – All indications are that Rob Konrad(28) has seen his last days as a Miami Dolphin. With a cap number of 1.25 million, he hasn’t made the impact that was expected when he was drafted in the 2nd round in 1999. This leaves J.Martin & likely S.Morris at FB. Martin (24) seemed more than capable of filling the role when playing last year. He doesn’t do anything in the passing game but Morris is adept at pass catching. IMO there doesn’t seem to be a need to add a FB in FA or the draft with these two capable players.

    TIGHT END – R.McMichael(25) is clearly one of the top TE’s in the AFC though he may not be as great as he thinks he is because he has yet to step up at critical moments in big games. He has a bright future ahead of him, but it is uncertain if it will be with Miami considering that this is the final year of his contract. Under Saban, McMike will need to show that he is more of a team oriented player and he needs to stop worrying about stats. Donald Lee(24) has all the physical tools but he hasn’t made the most of his abilities. Lee constantly makes critical mistakes. This is a big year for him because Saban will not tolerate his lack of focus. Because of McMike’s contract situation and the uncertain status of D.Lee, TE is a viable consideration in FA & the draft.

    OPTIONS…

    Anthony Becht(27) – Not a threat in the passing game.. is an excellent blocker with the size to punish people and good technique, would fit a team looking for some assistance in lieu of replacing otherwise mediocre blockers.

    Jermaine Wigging(33) – Had a career year (71 rec) in Linehan’s offense…a decent blocker, with above average hands. What separates him from other tight ends is speed, which is excellent for the position. He can elude most linebackers, and has the body control to seal off the rest. He is most effective running out routes to the sideline, consistently producing first down catches when defenses load up on deep coverage.

    Chad Lewis(33) - Knows how to get open. Reads coverages and finds seams. Runs fairly well and can beat most linebackers. Has sure hands. An effective interference blocker….Doesn't push people around when blocking. Is getting older.

    Freddie Jones(30) - He is big and fast, and can sneak behind the defense for the deep ball on occassion. He has good hands, but can get lost underneath and give up while attemption to elude a defender. He is not a superb blocker, but gets the job done effectively enough, but is prone to releasing too early.

    Heath Miller(R) - Has good athletic ability, showing the ability to get open and make plays once he does catch the ball. He has awesome hands, and will be a red zone threat for the team that drafts him. He is also a willing blocker, and is above average in this category.

    Other…Stephen Alexander, Ken Dilger, Patrick Hape, Cam Cleeland, Itula Mili, David Martin

    WIDE RECEIVERS – This would appear to be one the Dolphins strengths. C.Chambers(26) is in the prime of his career. Questions still arise as to whether he is an elite WR or the lack of talent around him has held him back. With an experienced OC in Linehan, we should begin to find out. Marty Booker(28) Is another WR who could greatly benefit from Linehan’s presence. He is still a solid playmaker. D.Thompson(27) & B.Gilmore(26) both showed flashes of ability in 2004…enough to warrant playing time in 3 & 4 WR sets next year. With reports circulating that David Boston(26) will be released by Saban for cap reasons, the need for another WR is there. It’s likely that Miami will look for a lesser known free agent or a rookie to fill his absence. For that reason I will not detail the big money free agent WR’s like Burress, Houshmandzadeh or Givens.

    OPTIONS…

    Braylon Edwards(R) – Emerging as the #1 rookie in this years class…He can go across the middle to make the tough catch, and he can go up and get the ball in the red zone to make the play. He specializes in making the spectacular grab. Has solid speed, and can get deep and outrun defenders to make the big play. Physically, he's got it all - Tall, strong, and has good speed. While Edwards can make the big catch, he often drops the easy one.

    Mike Williams (R) - Gets off the line easy, as he has excellent use of his hands, and the strength allows him to toss aside the corner before he can be neutralized. Great hands. Is going to be a major force in the red zone from his first snap in an NFL game. A very good blocker in the run game, and runs very precise routes…does not possess great speed, but it is not something that will hold him back in the NFL.

    Troy Edwards(27) - He is a great slot guy, with excellent hands and superb body control…has the foot quickness to be productive out of the slot but is too short and stocky to have success outside.

    -RFA- Kelly Campbell(24) – Has played all 3 years of his NFL career in S.Linehan’s offense…Has averaged close to 20 yds a catch on 44 receptions over the last 2 years..Very quick and elusive. Has long speed and can get separation. Snatches the ball and will make the tough catch…at 171 lbs, he’s small and slightly built. Loses focus and will drop passes. Is too small to start and cannot take a hit.

    (I only list Campbell because of his connection to Linehan- He was an undrafted free agent, so if the Vikings don’t tender him with the highest option, he may be available for little compensation.)

    Others…Charles Lee, Tai Streets, Troy Walters, Dane Looker

    Up next...DL, LB ASAP

  2. -2
    nando03's Avatar
    Fin Fan from MD

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Jul 2004
    Posts:
    1,338
    vCash:
    1293
    Loc:
    Arlington, VA
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Great Post, I'm curious to see what you think about the other side of the ball.

  3. -3
    Celtkin's Avatar
    Waterlogged

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Dec 2004
    Posts:
    14,810
    vCash:
    1000
    Loc:
    U. Idaho
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Good post, really it is but didn't you already post the same thing in a earlier thread with the same title?

  4. -4
    Regan21286's Avatar
    Wa Wa Wee Wa

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    May 2003
    Posts:
    5,465
    vCash:
    1000
    Loc:
    UCLA
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Long post but good. I would consider a lower round pick for Tackle if those don't pan out like maybe Barnes or Pettiti. I don't think Warner should even be considered for the Fins, that spot should be replaced by Griese if Tampa can't re-sign him.

    And so do people who don't vote for me in FH March Madness http://www.dolphinsnation.com/forums...d.php?t=215893
    Players I'm looking at for 08 draft: Adarius Bowman, DR Cromartie, Martin Rucker, Bruce Davis, Shannon Tevaga, Tracy Porter, Brian Brohm, Matt Ryan, Chris Long, John Carlson, Chauncey Washington (ex-HS teammate)
    Interesting fact: Bill Parcells was the 1st NFL coach to have Gatorade dumped on him after a W in 1985.

  5. -5
    Gladsadmad's Avatar
    Pro Bowler

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Mar 2003
    Posts:
    1,770
    vCash:
    1109
    Loc:
    West Palm Beach
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Quote Originally Posted by Celtkin
    Good post, really it is but didn't you already post the same thing in a earlier thread with the same title?
    I only did that in case ppl didn't see the QB, RB & TE breakdown..Don't worry I'm not a glory hog I just didn't want to break everything up.

  6. -6
    Samphin's Avatar
    Dolphins Homer

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Sep 2002
    Posts:
    9,158
    vCash:
    1217
    Loc:
    S.F. Bay Area
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Good post. I would disagree on some of the analysis, but overall, a very detailed and informative post. I really wnat to see a new LT and C but it looks like we may end up having retreads at both unless we break the bank.

    I also think that if Boston is cut, we won't replace him. I think we would just use Welker in the fifth spot. It isn't like he would be out there too often, unless injuries occured.

    If I recall, Minnesota used a lot of two TE sets in the last few years. If that is true, I would expect to see a lot of Donald Lee this upcoming year.

    We have a ton of options for RB. Glad mentioned about fifty million of them and that was without all of the rookies...

  7. -7
    Pro Bowler

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Oct 2003
    Posts:
    1,473
    vCash:
    1053
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Good post however I disagree with some of your options. For RB you left out all FA options...Edge,Alexander,Rudi,Henry, etc. theres still a possibility that we could pick up one of these guys for an instant impact at the position. Forget Blaylock, and those guys theyre obviously a product of a system, the guy had one of if not the best running offensive line in the NFL...he would be awful on the dolphins.

  8. -8
    PHINSfan's Avatar
    FinHeaven VIP

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Dec 2004
    Posts:
    2,008
    vCash:
    2704
    Loc:
    Broward, Fl.
    Thanks / No Thanks
    a very good post. I see you have added the rooks RB's in this one.
    Good job!!!

  9. -9
    LarryFinFan's Avatar
    Left So Fla, never the Fins...

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Mar 2004
    Posts:
    7,699
    vCash:
    1078
    Loc:
    NC
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Quote Originally Posted by Phinfan31
    Good post however I disagree with some of your options. For RB you left out all FA options...Edge,Alexander,Rudi,Henry, etc. theres still a possibility that we could pick up one of these guys for an instant impact at the position. Forget Blaylock, and those guys theyre obviously a product of a system, the guy had one of if not the best running offensive line in the NFL...he would be awful on the dolphins.

    Edge, Alexander, and Rudi have been tagged...we won't be going after them. Henry is unlikely because I don't think Saban wants to give up a draft pick. He has said a couple of times he wants to build thru the draft. The top 3 guys in the draft are very intriging, but will he go that way ?? I think only if he cannot find a trade-down suitor will he go RB with the #2.

  10. -10
    Dr.Rad's Avatar
    The Enforcer

    Status:
    Offline
    WPA:
    Join date:
    Mar 2004
    Posts:
    330
    vCash:
    1000
    Loc:
    Errrywhere
    Thanks / No Thanks
    Nice post man, but isn't Kelly Campbell slated to start in Minnesota this season now that Randy is gone?
    Have a nice day, make a new friend...[SIGPIC]

Similar Threads

  1. 2009 Position Analysis: LB
    By MrEd in forum Miami Dolphins Forum
    Replies: 42
    Last Post: 01-07-2009, 05:41 PM
  2. Position Analysis
    By FinFan57 in forum Miami Dolphins Forum
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 09-02-2005, 06:14 PM
  3. Replies: 7
    Last Post: 02-24-2005, 12:11 PM
  4. Replies: 8
    Last Post: 02-23-2005, 02:35 AM

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •