2024 Draft - Offensive Ranking

[LargoFin]

If they are not on the Big Board below, I am not interested.

QB

Day 1
Caleb Williams USC
Jayden Daniels LSU
Joe Milton TEN

Day 2
Michael Penix UW
Bo Nix ORE
Michael Pratt TUL

Day 3
Sam Hartman ND
Jordan Travis FSU
Tanner Mordecai WIS


WR

Day 1
Malik Nabers LSU

Day 2
Roman WIlson MICH
Hayden Hatten IDAHO

Day 3
Jermaine Burton ALA
Ryan Flournoy SE MIZZ
Brenden Rice USC
Troy Franklin ORE
Johnny Wilson FSU
Kaden Prather MD


TE

Day 1
Theo Johnson PSU

Day 2
Ben Sinnott KST

Day 3
Jaheem Bell (FB/TE) FSU


RB

Day 1
Isaac Guerendo LOU
Jaylen Wright TEN

Day 2
Kendall Milton UGA
Tyrone Tracy PUR

Day 3
George Holani BSU


LT

Day 1
Joe Alt ND (true tackle)
Frank Crum WYO (true tackle)
Kingsley Suamataia BYU (swing tackle, guard body)
Tylan Grable UCF (true tackle)

Day 2
Brandon Coleman TCU (true tackle)
Christian Jones TEX (guard body)
Tyler Guyton OU (true tackle)
Olu Fashanu PSU (true tackle)


RT

Day 1
Amarius Mims UGA (true tackle, left or right)
Roger Rosengarten UW (guard body)
Taliese Fuaga (true tackle)


IOL

Day 1
Graham Barton DUKE
Troy Fautanu UW (best position center)
Christian Haynes UCON (RG)
Tanor Bartolini WIS (center)

Day 2
Jordan Morgan AZ
Gottlieb Ayedze MD
Jarrett Kingston USC
Matt Lee MIA (center)

Day 3/UDFA
Matthew Jones tOSU
Delmar Glaze MD
Isaiah Adams ILL

 

[Kebo]

Not bad, but to not list Marvin Harrison Jr is just obnoxious.

 

[LargoFin]

Not bad, but to not list Marvin Harrison Jr is just obnoxious.

I don't like his frame. Same goes for Odunze, Brian Thomas. I would not draft them.

 

[phinfan33]

I don't like his frame. Same goes for Odunze, Brian Thomas. I would not draft them.

So his play on the field doesn't matter to you based on his frame?

 

[Carne Asada]

The game is not about physical profiles as much as it is about players. You're not picking a boyfriend. Grier & Co are picking a football roster.

Maybe if you looked for traits instead of physical profiles. Moneyball style. Statistics. Analytics.

Like, what matters at each position based on our scheme?

Under Flo, all that mattered as a MEG corner was staying in phase. So you look for CBs that give up the least separation in man coverage and so on

You use things like cone/40 times as CONFIRMATION of how translatable the trait is.

A CB that specializes in man coverage with a cone time over 7 secs and/or a 4.50+ plus 40 probably won't be able to win at the NFL level as a man only CB. However if he can jump out of the stadium he can probably play the flood side.

Get it?

 

[Zounds]

no brock bowers? dont like his frame either?

 

[LargoFin]

no brock bowers? dont like his frame either?

Bowers did not test. There is no data on him.

 

[Zounds]

Bowers did not test. There is no data on him.

Im pretty sure I saw him in plenty of games...you know, the ultimate test

 

[LargoFin]

Im pretty sure I saw him in plenty of games...you know, the ultimate test

Wrong thread, this is not eye-test ranking thread.

 

[Jamesw]

If they are not on the Big Board below, I am not interested.

QB

Day 1
Caleb Williams USC
Jayden Daniels LSU
Joe Milton TEN

Day 2
Michael Penix UW
Bo Nix ORE
Michael Pratt TUL

Day 3
Sam Hartman ND
Jordan Travis FSU
Tanner Mordecai WIS


WR

Day 1
Malik Nabers LSU

Day 2
Roman WIlson MICH
Hayden Hatten IDAHO

Day 3
Jermaine Burton ALA
Ryan Flournoy SE MIZZ
Brenden Rice USC
Troy Franklin ORE
Johnny Wilson FSU
Kaden Prather MD


TE

Day 1
Theo Johnson PSU

Day 2
Ben Sinnott KST

Day 3
Jaheem Bell (FB/TE) FSU


RB

Day 1
Isaac Guerendo LOU
Jaylen Wright TEN

Day 2
Kendall Milton UGA
Tyrone Tracy PUR

Day 3
George Holani BSU


LT

Day 1
Joe Alt ND (true tackle)
Frank Crum WYO (true tackle)
Kingsley Suamataia BYU (swing tackle, guard body)
Tylan Grable UCF (true tackle)

Day 2
Brandon Coleman TCU (true tackle)
Christian Jones TEX (guard body)
Tyler Guyton OU (true tackle)
Olu Fashanu PSU (true tackle)


RT

Day 1
Amarius Mims UGA (true tackle, left or right)
Roger Rosengarten UW (guard body)
Taliese Fuaga (true tackle)


IOL

Day 1
Graham Barton DUKE
Troy Fautanu UW (best position center)
Christian Haynes UCON (RG)
Tanor Bartolini WIS (center)

Day 2
Jordan Morgan AZ
Gottlieb Ayedze MD
Jarrett Kingston USC
Matt Lee MIA (center)

Day 3/UDFA
Matthew Jones tOSU
Delmar Glaze MD
Isaiah Adams ILL

With respect, how does anyone have Joe Milton as a day 1 QB? I've only seen him rated as a day 3 pick.

 

[LargoFin]

With respect, how does anyone have Joe Milton as a day 1 QB? I've only seen him rated as a day 3 pick.

It's intentional. People have Drake Maye who sucked in college as top 5 pick. Last year Anthony Richardson who absolutely sucked in college was top 10 pick, and so on. Will Levis who was terrible in college was touted as day 1 pick. Going back year after year to Josh Allen, Darnold, our own Tannehill, Rosen, list goes on and on.
I am objective, if all those guys were day 1 picks, Joe Milton 100% is a day 1 pick. The others are not objective, and more than that, they are wrong for doing it like that, they are inconsistent.