Wilkins weighs in on Tua being “overrated”

[Mello Yello]

The fact he was asked shows that there's still interest in the topic of who Tua is and what exactly he brings.

Until that's firmly answered by winning big games there will be doubt and his ex-teammates will be asked these types of questions.

 

[1972forever]

Despite what they say publicly, I would tend to believe the players on the team have varying degrees of thoughts on Tua and his abilities.

Similar to the forum here.

Players on the team likely have varying degrees of thoughts concerning every player and coach on the Dolphins. It’s called thinking for yourself and everyone has that ability.

 

[SF Dolphin Fan]

This is a non-story. No need to overreact.

 

[Beach Bum]

Overrated my ass! Tua is who we thought he would be...

 

[andyahs]

The fact he was asked shows that there's still interest in the topic of who Tua is and what exactly he brings.

Until that's firmly answered by winning big games there will be doubt and his ex-teammates will be asked these types of questions.

What crap.

Who is Wilkins? How many games did Wilkins win for us?

 

[Bob512]

I don't get how anyone can watch that clip and not take Wilkins comments as both positive and supportive

 

[andyahs]

I don't get how anyone can watch that clip and not take Wilkins comments as both positive and supportive

Same ones who turn every positive Tua thread around to fit their narrative.

 

[TurboDurden]

Spot on. Tua is a great regular season QB like Phillip Rivers was or Dak Prescott currently is. Unfortunately, this isn't lame a** college football where the regular season actually means anything, other than qualifying for the real season. Until Tua starts winning in the real season he will be just like Lamar, a choke artist. Hopefully that changes in 2024/25.

Just like Marino! Choke artist! Bum! He couldn't even win the big one in lame ass college football. Wish we had drafted Eli Manning, a real QB who won games when it mattered.

Are you not embarrassed when you read your own comments?

 

[NBP81]

Tua ranks much better in production than any "experts" QB rankings lists out there... Not sure how one could make an argument he's any kind of overrated right now...

 

[jimthefin]

Wilkins is and was a good dude.

Too bad Miami couldn't make the money work but I have no hard feelings towards the guy at all.

 

[TannDaMan17]

Just like Marino! Choke artist! Bum! He couldn't even win the big one in lame ass college football. Wish we had drafted Eli Manning, a real QB who won games when it mattered.

Are you not embarrassed when you read your own comments?

If Marino had 1 ring or more he would at least be in the GOAT conversation, without one he is not. I do wish we drafted Eli Manning, who will be going to the Hall of Fame and deservedly so for the exact reason I mentioned, the playoffs. A .500 QB will be going to the Hall of Fame, remind me again how anything else matters in professional football other than the playoffs lmfao. And I'm sure Mahomes would be viewed exactly the same without the rings

They built Nick Foles a statue in Philly and he will never have to buy himself a beer in that s***hole city ever again. I'm sure Philly would feel the exact same way about him if he came up 1 yard shy in the SB and the rest of the NFC East could still troll them for being the only team in the division without a ring to this day

Like it or not, Vince Lombardi was right all along. People are just soft these days and can't handle the truth about professional sports. There is no second place.

 

[Duss]

Spot on. Tua is a great regular season QB like Phillip Rivers was or Dak Prescott currently is. Unfortunately, this isn't lame a** college football where the regular season actually means anything, other than qualifying for the real season. Until Tua starts winning in the real season he will be just like Lamar, a choke artist. Hopefully that changes in 2024/25.

That’s a dumb take he only played 1 postseason game and lost to the SB winner… f

Plus playoff record is ludicrous look st jimmy G and dilfer

 

[TannDaMan17]

That’s a dumb take he only played 1 postseason game and lost to the SB winner… f

Plus playoff record is ludicrous look st jimmy G and dilfer

We’re going on year 5. He needs to win in the playoffs immediately.

 

[Sticky Gloves]

We’re going on year 5. He needs to win in the playoffs immediately.

I'm more concerned with his record against playoff level teams than any one playoff game. That tells more of a story.

 

[TannDaMan17]

I'm more concerned with his record against playoff level teams than any one playoff game. That tells more of a story.

Well if he hadn’t played so poorly down the stretch we wouldn’t have faced the Chiefs and probably would’ve won a playoff game. It all adds up.